diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index 3ddfef68da2d49d41850009d0e3bfeba4d97f569..137a4eae81d055eb4aebb68d2c4977ad0bb5fce4 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -120,19 +120,19 @@ We define four preferences for the dictator, each corresponding to a distinct fo
We consider four allocation options where part of the money is lost in the division process,
each corresponding to one of the four preferences:
-- The dictator keeps **$500**, the recipient receives **$100**, and a total of **$400** is lost (**egoistic**).
-- The dictator keeps **$100**, the recipient receives **$500**, and **$400** is lost (**altruistic**).
-- The dictator keeps **$400**, the recipient receives **$300**, resulting in a loss of **$300** (**utilitarian**).
-- The dictator keeps **$325**, the other player receives **$325**, and **$350** is lost (**egalitarian**).
+- The dictator keeps **$500, the recipient receives $100, and a total of $400 is lost (**egoistic**).
+- The dictator keeps **$100, the recipient receives $500, and $400 is lost (**altruistic**).
+- The dictator keeps **$400, the recipient receives $300, resulting in a loss of $300 (**utilitarian**).
+- The dictator keeps **$325, the other player receives $325, and $350 is lost (**egalitarian**).
Table below evaluates the ability of the models to align with different preferences.
- When generating **strategies**, the models align perfectly with preferences, except for <tt>DeepSeek-R1<tt> and <tt>Mixtral:8x7b</tt> which do not generate valid code.
- When generating **actions**,
- - <tt>GPT-4.5<tt> aligns well with preferences but struggles with **utilitarianism**.
- - <tt>Llama3<tt> aligns well with **egoistic** and **altruistic** preferences but shows lower adherence to **utilitarian** and **egalitarian** choices.
+ - <tt>GPT-4.5</tt> aligns well with preferences but struggles with **utilitarianism**.
+ - <tt>Llama3</tt> aligns well with **egoistic** and **altruistic** preferences but shows lower adherence to **utilitarian** and **egalitarian** choices.
- <tt>Mistral-Small</tt> aligns better with **altruistic** preferences and performs moderately on **utilitarianism** but struggles with **egoistic** and **egalitarian** preferences.
- <tt>DeepSeek-R1</tt> primarily aligns with **utilitarianism** but has low accuracy in other preferences.
-While a larger LLM typically aligns better with preferences, a model like Mixtral-8x7B may occasionally
+While a larger LLM typically aligns better with preferences, a model like <tt>Mixtral-8x7B</tt> may occasionally
underperform compared to its smaller counterpart, Mistral-Small due to their architectural complexity.
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models, like Mixtral, dynamically activate only a subset of their parameters.
If the routing mechanism isn’t well-tuned, it might select less optimal experts, leading to degraded performance.
@@ -213,26 +213,35 @@ We first evaluate the rationality of the agents and then their second-order rati
Table below evaluates the models’ ability to generate rational
behaviour for Player 2.
-| **Model** | **Generation** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** |
-|--------------------|--------------|----------|------------|------------|
-| `gpt-4.5` | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
-| `mistral-small` | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
-| `llama3` | strategy | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 |
-| `deepseek-r1` | strategy | - | - | - |
-| **—** | **—** | **—** | **—** | **—** |
-| `gpt-4.5` | actions | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
-| `mistral-small` | actions | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.87 |
-| `llama3` | actions | 1.00 | 0.90 | 0.17 |
-| `deepseek-r1` | actions | 0.83 | 0.57 | 0.60 |
-
-When generating strategies, GPT-4.5 and Mistral-Small exhibit
-rational behaviour, whereas Llama3 adopts a random strategy.
-DeepSeek-R1 fails to generate valid output. When generating actions,
-GPT-4.5 demonstrates its ability to make rational decisions, even with
-implicit beliefs. Mistral-Small outperforms other open-weight models.
-Llama3 struggles to infer optimal actions based solely on implicit
-beliefs. DeepSeek-R1 is not a good candidate for simulating
-rationality.
+| **Model** | **Generation** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** |
+|-------------------|--------------|-----------|--------------|--------------|
+| <tt>gpt-4.5</tt> | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| <tt>mixtral:8x7b</tt> | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| <tt>mistral-small</tt> | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| <tt>llama3.3:latest</tt> | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.50 |
+| <tt>llama3</tt> | strategy | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 |
+| <tt>deepseek-r1:7b</tt> | strategy | - | - | - |
+| <tt>deepseek-r1</tt> | strategy | - | - | - |
+| **—** | **—** | **—** | **—** | **—** |
+| <tt>gpt-4.5</tt> | actions | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| <tt>mixtral:8x7b</tt> | actions | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| <tt>mistral-small</tt> | actions | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.87 |
+| <tt>llama33:latest</tt> | actions | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| <tt>llama3.3</tt> | actions | 1.00 | 0.90 | 0.17 |
+| <tt>deepseek-r1:7b</tt> | actions | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| <tt>deepseek-r1</tt> | actions | 0.83 | 0.57 | 0.60 |
+
+
+When generating strategies, <tt>GPT-4.5</tt>, <tt>Mixtral-8x7B</tt>, and <tt>Mistral-Small</tt>
+exhibit rational behavior, whereas <tt>Llama3</tt> adopts a random rationality.
+<tt>Llama3.3:latest</tt> has the same behaviour with implicit beliefs.
+<tt>Deepseek-R1:7b</tt> and <tt>DeepSeek-R1</tt> fails to generate valid strategies.
+When generating actions, <tt>GPT-4.5</tt>, <tt>Mixtral-8x7B</tt>, <tt>DeepSeek-R1:7b</tt>,
+and <tt>Llama3.3:latest<</tt> demonstrate strong rational decision-making, even with implicit beliefs.
+<tt>Mistral-Small</tt> performs well but slightly lags in handling implicit reasoning.
+<tt>Llama3</tt> struggles with implicit reasoning, while <tt>DeepSeek-R1</tt>
+shows inconsistent performance.
+Overall, <tt>GPT-4.5</tt> and <tt>Mixtral-8x7B</tt> are the most reliable models for generating rational behavior.
### Second-Order Rationality
@@ -269,17 +278,23 @@ difficulties with implicit beliefs, especially in variant (d).
DeepSeek-R1 does not appear to be a good candidate for simulating
second-order rationality.
-| **Version** | | **a** | | | **b** | | | **c** | | | **d** | | |
-|-------------|----------------|---------------|----------|----------|---------------|----------|----------|---------------|----------|----------|---------------|----------|----------|
-| **Model** | **Generation** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** |
-| **gpt-4.5** | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
-| **llama3** | strategy | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 |
-| **mistral-small** | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
-| **deepseek-r1** | strategy | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
-| **gpt-4.5** | actions | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.67 | 0.00 | 0.86 | 0.83 | 0.00 | 0.50 | 0.90 | 0.00 |
-| **llama3** | actions | 0.97 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.77 | 0.80 | 0.60 | 0.97 | 0.90 | 0.93 | 0.83 | 0.90 | 0.60 |
-| **mistral-small** | actions | 0.93 | 0.97 | 1.00 | 0.87 | 0.77 | 0.60 | 0.77 | 0.60 | 0.70 | 0.73 | 0.57 | 0.37 |
-| **deepseek-r1** | actions | 0.80 | 0.53 | 0.57 | 0.67 | 0.60 | 0.53 | 0.67 | 0.63 | 0.47 | 0.70 | 0.50 | 0.57 |
+| **Version** | | **a** | | | **b** | | | **c** | | | **d** | | |
+|---------------------|----------------|-----------|--------------|--------------|-----------|--------------|--------------|-----------|--------------|--------------|-----------|--------------|--------------|
+| **Model** | **Generation** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** | **Given** | **Explicit** | **Implicit** |
+| **gpt-4.5** | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| **llama3.3:latest** | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.50 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.50 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.50 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.50 |
+| **llama3** | strategy | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.50 |
+| **mixtral:8x7b** | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| **mistral-small** | strategy | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
+| **deepseek-r1:7b** | strategy | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
+| **deepseek-r1** | strategy | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
+| **gpt-4.5** | actions | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.67 | 0.00 | 0.86 | 0.83 | 0.00 | 0.50 | 0.90 | 0.00 |
+| **llama3.3:latest** | actions | 0.97TODO | 1.00TODO | 1.00TODO | 0.77TODO | 0.80TODO | 0.60TODO | 0.97TODO | 0.90TODO | 0.93TODO | 0.83TODO | 0.90TODO | 0.60TODO |
+| **llama3** | actions | 0.97 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.77 | 0.80 | 0.60 | 0.97 | 0.90 | 0.93 | 0.83 | 0.90 | 0.60 |
+| **mixtral:8x7b** | actions | 0.93TODO | 0.97TODO | 1.00TODO | 0.87TODO | 0.77TODO | 0.60TODO | 0.77TODO | 0.60TODO | 0.70TODO | 0.73TODO | 0.57TODO | 0.37TODO |
+| **mistral-small** | actions | 0.93 | 0.97 | 1.00 | 0.87 | 0.77 | 0.60 | 0.77 | 0.60 | 0.70 | 0.73 | 0.57 | 0.37 |
+| **deepseek-r1:7b** | actions | 0.80TODO | 0.53TODO | 0.57TODO | 0.67TODO | 0.60TODO | 0.53TODO | 0.67TODO | 0.63TODO | 0.47TODO | 0.70TODO | 0.50TODO | 0.57TODO |
+| **deepseek-r1** | actions | 0.80 | 0.53 | 0.57 | 0.67 | 0.60 | 0.53 | 0.67 | 0.63 | 0.47 | 0.70 | 0.50 | 0.57 |
Irrational decisions are explained by inference errors based on the natural
language description of the payoff matrix. For example, in variant (d), the
diff --git a/data/ring/ring.2.a.csv b/data/ring/ring.2.a.csv
index 047f151e9377873d60d2a04f86b6594f0d65f370..a1a11ab8f2551e1809d4cc9967b4353302bd683d 100644
--- a/data/ring/ring.2.a.csv
+++ b/data/ring/ring.2.a.csv
@@ -358,4 +358,279 @@ Iteration,Model,Temperature,Belief,action,rationality,reasoning
27,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Exploring the possibility of mutual cooperation to achieve higher collective payoff."""
28,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I need to maximize my own payoff while considering Player 1's possible moves."""
29,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,
-30,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,
\ No newline at end of file
+30,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,
+1,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A ensures a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A, which is better than the 5 points I'd get with B. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 5 points with A, whereas I would get 0 points with B. Thus, choosing A maximizes my payoff in both scenarios."""
+2,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, it means that regardless of Player 1's move, choosing B will always yield a better or equal payoff for me (Player 2) compared to choosing A. Therefore, as a rational player, I must choose B to maximize my own payoff."""
+3,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A will always result in a better or equal payoff for me (Player 2) regardless of Player 1's action. Therefore, as a rational player, I must choose A to maximize my own payoff."""
+4,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B ensures a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's action. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B, which is better than the 5 points I'd get with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with B, which is better than the 0 points I'd get with A. Thus, choosing B maximizes my payoff in all scenarios."""
+5,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, regardless of Player 1's choice, choosing A yields a better or equal payoff compared to choosing B. Therefore, as a rational player, I choose A to maximize my potential payoff."""
+6,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B guarantees a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B, which is better than the 5 points I would get with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with B, which is better than the 0 points I would get with A. Thus, choosing B maximizes my payoff in all scenarios."""
+7,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, regardless of Player 1's choice, choosing A will always yield a better or equal payoff compared to choosing B. Thus, as a rational player, I choose A to maximize my potential payoff."""
+8,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B guarantees a higher or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's action. If Player 1 chooses Y, choosing B gives me 10 points, which is better than the 5 points I would get if I chose A. If Player 1 chooses X, choosing B gives me 5 points, which is better than the 0 points I would get if I chose A. Therefore, as a rational player, I must choose B to maximize my payoff."""
+9,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A will always result in a better or equal payoff for me regardless of Player 1's action. Therefore, as a rational player, I choose A to maximize my potential payoff."""
+10,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since option A is strictly dominated by B, meaning B yields a better or equal payoff than A for every possible move of Player 1, choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's decision."""
+11,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing A provides a higher or equal payoff than choosing B regardless of Player 1's action, making it the rational choice for maximizing payoff."""
+12,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B will always result in a higher payoff for me regardless of Player 1's action. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B compared to 5 points with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with B, which is better than getting 0 points with A."""
+13,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""A strictly dominates B because it yields a better payoff regardless of Player 1's move. Choosing A guarantees at least 5 points, whereas choosing B could result in 0 points if Player 1 chooses Y."""
+14,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, it means that regardless of Player 1's move (X or Y), choosing B will always yield a better or equal payoff for me compared to choosing A. Therefore, as a rational player, I choose B to maximize my payoff."""
+15,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, regardless of Player 1's action, choosing A will always yield a better or equal payoff compared to choosing B. Therefore, as a rational player, I choose A to maximize my potential payoff."""
+16,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B guarantees a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B, which is better than the 5 points I would get with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with B, which is better than the 0 points I would get with A. Thus, choosing B maximizes my payoff."""
+17,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing A strictly dominates choosing B, as it provides a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's action."""
+18,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""I chose B because it is the rational choice given that A is strictly dominated by B. Regardless of Player 1's move, choosing B maximizes my payoff or at least ensures I don't receive a lower payoff compared to choosing A."""
+19,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A but only 5 points with B. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 5 points with A and 0 points with B. Thus, A is the rational choice to ensure a higher or equal payoff in all scenarios."""
+20,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B guarantees a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses Y, choosing B gives me 10 points instead of 5 points if I chose A. If Player 1 chooses X, choosing B gives me 5 points, which is better than 0 points if I chose A. Therefore, as a rational player, I must choose B to maximize my payoff."""
+21,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""I chose A because it is the rational choice given that B is strictly dominated by A. Regardless of Player 1's move, choosing A gives me a better or equal payoff compared to choosing B. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A versus 5 points with B. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 5 points with A versus 0 points with B. Therefore, A is the optimal choice to maximize my payoff."""
+22,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""I chose B because it is the rational choice given that A is strictly dominated by B. Regardless of Player 1's move, choosing B guarantees me a payoff (either 10 points if Player 1 chooses Y or 5 points if Player 1 chooses X), whereas choosing A could result in a payoff of 0 if Player 1 chooses X."""
+23,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, regardless of Player 1's move, choosing A always yields a better or equal payoff for me as Player 2. Therefore, to maximize my payoff rationally, I must choose A."""
+24,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B will always yield a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B, which is better than the 5 points I'd get with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with B, which is better than the 0 points I'd get with A. Therefore, as a rational player, I must choose B to maximize my payoff."""
+25,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing A is the rational decision because it yields a better or equal payoff than choosing B, regardless of Player 1's action. Given that B is strictly dominated by A, selecting A maximizes my potential payoff."""
+26,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, it means that regardless of Player 1's move, choosing B will always result in a better or equal payoff for me (Player 2) compared to choosing A. Therefore, as a rational player, I must choose B to maximize my own payoff."""
+27,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, regardless of Player 1's action, choosing A will always yield a better or equal payoff compared to choosing B. Therefore, as a rational player, I must choose A to maximize my payoff."""
+28,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, regardless of Player 1's action, choosing B will always yield a better or equal payoff compared to choosing A. Therefore, as a rational player, I must choose B to maximize my payoff."""
+29,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, regardless of Player 1's choice (X or Y), choosing A always results in a higher or equal payoff for me compared to choosing B. Thus, to maximize my payoff, I choose A."""
+30,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B ensures a higher payoff for me regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B, which is better than the 5 points I would get with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with B, which is better than the 0 points I would get with A. Thus, B is the rational choice to maximize my payoff."""
+1,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A provides either a higher or equal payoff for every possible choice made by Player 1."""
+2,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""B is strictly dominant over A, meaning it provides a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's action."""
+3,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""A is strictly dominant over B, providing a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's move."""
+4,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""B is strictly dominant over A, meaning it yields a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's action."""
+5,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A guarantees a better or equal payoff for me regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+6,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's action."""
+7,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's move, as B is strictly dominated by A."""
+8,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Option A is strictly dominated by option B. Regardless of what Player 1 chooses (X or Y), choosing B yields a better payoff for me than choosing A."""
+9,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's move."""
+10,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B ensures a higher or equal payoff for me regardless of Player 1's move."""
+11,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A ensures a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's decision."""
+12,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, it means that regardless of Player 1's move (X or Y), choosing B will always result in a better or equal payoff for me compared to choosing A. Therefore, the rational choice is to choose B to maximize my payoff."""
+13,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A guarantees a better or equal payoff for me regardless of Player 1's move."""
+14,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's move."""
+15,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's move because it is not strictly dominated by B and yields a higher or equal payoff in all scenarios."""
+16,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""B is strictly dominant over A, meaning it yields a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's move."""
+17,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A ensures a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's action."""
+18,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since option A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+19,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, meaning A provides either an equal or better outcome for Player 2 regardless of Player 1's choice, the rational decision is to choose A to maximize payoff."""
+20,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B ensures a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's choice, thus maximizing my potential payoff."""
+21,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my payoff in all scenarios because it is not strictly dominated by B and yields a better or equal outcome than B for every possible choice by Player 1."""
+22,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""B is strictly dominant over A, meaning it provides a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's action."""
+23,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""A is strictly dominant over B because it yields a better or equal payoff for every possible move by Player 1."""
+24,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B ensures a higher or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's action."""
+25,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's decision, as it provides a better or equal outcome compared to choosing B in all scenarios."""
+26,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's move because it is not strictly dominated by A and yields a better or equal outcome in all scenarios."""
+27,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""A is strictly dominant over B because it yields a better or equal payoff than B for every possible move by Player 1."""
+28,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes our payoff regardless of Player 1's choice because B is strictly dominant over A."""
+29,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""A strictly dominates B, offering a better or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's move."""
+30,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""B strictly dominates A because it yields a higher or equal payoff for every possible move by Player 1."""
+1,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A guarantees a minimum payoff of 5 points and potentially up to 10 points, depending on Player 1's move, thus maximizing our payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+2,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B ensures I receive at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's action and has the potential for a higher payoff of 10 points if Player 1 chooses Y."""
+3,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my minimum payoff, as it guarantees at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's move, and offers a higher potential payoff of 10 points if Player 1 chooses X."""
+4,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my potential payoff by ensuring I receive at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's move, with a higher payoff of 10 points if Player 1 chooses Y."""
+5,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my potential payoff with a chance at 10 points if Player 1 chooses X, and still provides a moderate payoff of 5 points if they choose Y."""
+6,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes our potential payoff without knowing Player 1's move, as it offers a higher reward if Player 1 chooses Y and avoids the worst-case scenario of 0 points if Player 1 chooses X."""
+7,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my minimum potential payoff regardless of Player 1's action, ensuring I receive at least 5 points in all scenarios."""
+8,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B guarantees at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's move, maximizing my minimum potential payoff."""
+9,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A provides a consistent and higher potential payoff regardless of Player 1's move, maximizing my chances for a better outcome."""
+10,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""To maximize my payoff, I choose B as it offers the highest potential reward across all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points, and if they choose X, I still get 5 points, making B the safest choice for maximizing my payoff."""
+11,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""I chose A because it guarantees me at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's action, maximizing my minimum payoff in an uncertain scenario."""
+12,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""To maximize the minimum potential payoff without knowing Player 1's move, choosing B guarantees at least 5 points regardless of whether Player 1 chooses X or Y."""
+13,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A provides the highest payoff if Player 1 chooses X and avoids the worst outcome (0 points) if Player 1 chooses Y, thus maximizing our minimum possible gain."""
+14,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I chose B because it maximizes my minimum guaranteed payoff. Regardless of Player 1's move, choosing B ensures I get at least 5 points, which is better than the potential 0 points if I choose A and Player 1 chooses X."""
+15,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""I chose A because it offers the highest potential payoff (10 points) and avoids the worst-case scenario of getting 0 points, which would happen if I chose B and Player 1 chose Y."""
+16,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes our payoff regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses X, we get 5 points with B instead of 0 with A. If Player 1 chooses Y, we get 10 points with B instead of 5 with A."""
+17,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes the potential payoff with 10 points if Player 1 chooses X, and minimizes loss with 5 points if Player 1 chooses Y, compared to choosing B which could result in 0 points."""
+18,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff in both the best and worst-case scenarios based on Player 1's possible choices."""
+19,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my minimum potential payoff regardless of Player 1's decision, offering a guarantee of at least 5 points and a potential for up to 10 points."""
+20,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my minimum potential payoff, as it offers 10 points if Player 1 chooses Y and 5 points if Player 1 chooses X, thereby ensuring I receive a positive payoff regardless of Player 1's decision."""
+21,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""I chose A because it offers the highest potential payoff (10 points) and also provides a safety net with a non-zero payoff (5 points) if Player 1 chooses Y, thus maximizing my expected payoff given the uncertainty of Player 1's action."""
+22,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I chose B to maximize my minimum guaranteed payoff. Regardless of Player 1's move, choosing B ensures I get at least 5 points, which is better than the risk of getting 0 points if I choose A and Player 1 chooses X."""
+23,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my potential payoff by avoiding the worst-case scenario (0 points) and ensuring at least 5 points, while also having the potential for a higher payoff (10 points) if Player 1 chooses X."""
+24,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my potential payoff regardless of Player 1's action, offering a balance between the highest possible reward and a decent fallback."""
+25,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my minimum payoff since it guarantees at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's choice, whereas choosing B could result in 0 points if Player 1 chooses Y."""
+26,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my minimum payoff regardless of Player 1's action, ensuring I receive at least 5 points in all scenarios."""
+27,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my minimum payoff regardless of Player 1's action, ensuring I receive at least 5 points in all scenarios."""
+28,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my potential payoff regardless of Player 1's move, avoiding the risk of receiving 0 points."""
+29,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my potential payoff with a chance at 10 points if Player 1 chooses X, and limits my loss to 5 points if Player 1 chooses Y, making it the most rational choice given the game's rules."""
+30,llama3.3:latest,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I choose B because it provides a consistent and potentially higher payoff regardless of Player 1's action, minimizing risk and maximizing potential reward."""
+1,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing A results in higher payoffs for Player 2 regardless of Player 1's choice. When Player 1 chooses X, you get 10 points instead of 5 when choosing B. When Player 1 chooses Y, you still get 5 points instead of 0. Therefore, A is the optimal choice."""
+2,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Action B strictly dominates Action A because Player 2 receives higher points (10 vs. 5) when Player 1 chooses Y and higher points (5 vs. 0) when Player 1 chooses X."""
+3,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A, so choosing A maximizes my payoff."""
+4,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's move."""
+5,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A will always result in a higher or equal payoff compared to choosing B, regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+6,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""A is strictly dominated by B, meaning that regardless of Player 1's choice, selecting B yields a higher payoff than selecting A."""
+7,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A for Player 2, so choosing A guarantees higher or equal payoffs compared to B. Therefore, I must choose A as it maximizes my own payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+8,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's strategy."""
+9,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' yields a better payoff than 'B' in all scenarios."""
+10,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B guarantees a better or equal outcome for Player 2 regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+11,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff in both possible scenarios regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+12,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B always results in higher or equal payoffs for me compared to A, regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+13,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing A strictly dominates B for Player 2 in all possible scenarios. Therefore, Player 2 will choose A."""
+14,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""A is strictly dominated by B, so choosing B maximizes Player 2's payoff in all scenarios."""
+15,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my minimum payoff in all scenarios."""
+16,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B yields a higher payoff in both scenarios (Player 1 choosing Y or X)."""
+17,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Player 2's move A consistently yields higher payoffs than B regardless of Player 1's choice. Therefore, choosing A maximizes Player 2's payoff."""
+18,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' results in a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+19,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' provides a better or equal payoff compared to 'B', regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+20,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""As Player 2, 'A' is strictly dominated by 'B'. Choosing A results in lower payoffs (5 or 0 points) compared to choosing B (10 or 5 points). Since rationality dictates selecting the optimal strategy, I choose B."""
+21,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, I choose 'A' because it dominates strategy B in all scenarios. Choosing A ensures higher or equal payoffs regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+22,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since 'A' is strictly dominated by 'B', choosing B ensures better outcomes in all scenarios."""
+23,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since choosing B is strictly dominated by A for Player 2, I should choose A to maximize my payoff. This ensures higher points regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+24,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""A is strictly dominated by B, so Player 2 will choose B to maximize their payoff."""
+25,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A. Choosing A yields a higher payoff for all possible moves of Player 1."""
+26,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""A is strictly dominated by B. Choosing B maximizes Player 2's payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+27,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A maximizes my minimum payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+28,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, Player 2 should choose B to maximize their payoff."""
+29,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A, so choosing A maximizes my payoffs."""
+30,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B yields a higher payoff (10 or 5 points) compared to choosing A (5 or 0 points). Additionally, 'A' is strictly dominated by 'B,' making it the rational choice."""
+1,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' yields a higher payoff than 'B' regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+2,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+3,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my minimum payoff since it results in higher points than choosing 'B' in all possible situations."""
+4,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since 'A' is strictly dominated by 'B', choosing B always results in a higher payoff for me compared to A, regardless of Player 1's choice. Therefore, I will choose B."""
+5,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A, so I choose A to ensure the highest possible payoff."""
+6,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' dominates 'A' because it yields higher payoffs regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+7,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' results in a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice (either X or Y)."""
+8,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Player 1 will rationally choose their dominant strategy B. As Player 2, choosing B gives the highest payoff of 10 points."""
+9,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A. Choosing A guarantees higher payoffs for me regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+10,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B ensures a higher payoff as it strictly dominates A."""
+11,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A, so choosing A guarantees a better outcome than choosing B in all scenarios."""
+12,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""A is strictly dominated by B, so choosing B will result in a higher or equal payoff compared to choosing A regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+13,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Option B is strictly worse than A for all of my possible choices (X and Y) by Player 1. Therefore, choosing A guarantees me the highest possible payoff."""
+14,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' yields higher points (10 when Player 1 chooses Y and 5 when Player 1 chooses X) compared to choosing 'A', which gives lower or equal points in both cases."""
+15,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Action A strictly dominates action B because it yields higher payoffs regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+16,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B strictly dominates A, as it yields higher payoffs in all scenarios."""
+17,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A, meaning choosing A always yields a higher payoff for me compared to choosing B."""
+18,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""A is strictly dominated by B, so choosing B will always yield a better outcome than A."""
+19,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A. Choosing A guarantees at least 5 points, while choosing B could result in 0 points if Player 1 chooses Y."""
+20,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Action A is strictly dominated by B, meaning choosing B always yields a higher or equal payoff compared to A regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+21,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. When Player 1 chooses X or Y, I receive 10 points and 5 points respectively, which are both higher than the alternatives."""
+22,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""A is strictly dominated by B, so choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+23,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' provides a higher payoff in both scenarios compared to 'B'."""
+24,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Action A is strictly dominated by B, ensuring a better or equal payoff in all scenarios."""
+25,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes the minimum guaranteed payoff since B is strictly dominated by A."""
+26,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Action A is strictly dominated by B in all scenarios, so selecting B maximizes my payoff."""
+27,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' yields a higher payoff (5 or 10 points) compared to choosing 'B' which gives only 0 or 5 points."""
+28,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""The strategy A is strictly dominated by B. Choosing B ensures a better or equal outcome for Player 2 compared to choosing A in all scenarios."""
+29,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I should choose A because it provides a higher payoff regardless of whether Player 1 chooses X or Y."""
+30,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""A is strictly dominated by B, and choosing B yields better outcomes regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+1,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' provides a higher or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's choice, making it the optimal strategy."""
+2,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes your payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, you get 10 points; if they choose X, you still get 5 points."""
+3,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A provides a better or equal outcome compared to choosing B. If Player 1 chooses X, I gain 10 points; if they choose Y, I still get at least 5 points."""
+4,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' yields a higher payoff (10 or 5 points) compared to choosing 'A' (5 or 0 points), regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+5,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A yields the highest possible payoff (10 points when Player 1 chooses X and 5 points when Player 1 chooses Y). This action dominates all other options for maximizing my own payoff."""
+6,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B yields higher points (10 vs. 5 and 5 vs. 0) regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+7,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' provides the highest possible payoff in both scenarios."""
+8,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' yields the highest guaranteed payoff regardless of Player 1's action."""
+9,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A ensures at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+10,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff in all possible scenarios."""
+11,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' is optimal because if Player 1 selects X, it yields the highest payoff for Player 2 (10 points), and in the case of Y selection by Player 1, it still provides a better payoff than selecting B (5 vs. 0). Thus, 'A' maximizes the minimum expected payoff."""
+12,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes your payoff in both scenarios where Player 1 chooses Y or X."""
+13,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A gives me more points in both possible scenarios."""
+14,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff in both scenarios: receiving either 10 points when Player 1 chooses Y or 5 points when Player 1 chooses X."""
+15,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' consistently maximizes my payoff in all possible situations."""
+16,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my minimum payoff across all possible choices of Player 1."""
+17,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my payoff in both scenarios where Player 1 picks X or Y."""
+18,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B yields the highest payoff (10 or 5 points) regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+19,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+20,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' ensures at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's move, whereas 'A' could result in 0 points if Player 1 chooses X."""
+21,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my minimum payoff regardless of Player 1's strategy."""
+22,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff irrespective of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if they choose X, I still get 5 points, which is better than any other option."""
+23,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' yields a higher payoff (10 or 5 points) compared to 'B' (5 or 0 points) regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+24,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes your payoff in both scenarios where Player 1 chooses Y or X."""
+25,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes your payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. When Player 1 selects X or Y, choosing 'A' results in higher points (10 vs. 5) compared to 'B' which gives lower points."""
+26,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B yields higher payoffs regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y or X, B gives a better outcome than A."""
+27,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing A provides a better or equal payoff (10 points) against both possible choices of Player 1 (X and Y)."""
+28,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B yields a higher payoff (10 points) if Player 1 selects Y, which is more beneficial than choosing A (5 points in that scenario). Additionally, when Player 1 selects X, both choices of B and A result in equal payoffs. Therefore, selecting B aligns with maximizing the potential mutual benefit."""
+29,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' yields a higher payoff in both possible scenarios based on Player 1's choices."""
+30,deepseek-r1:7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B results in the highest possible payoffs for both of my choices, regardless of Player 1's strategy."""
+1,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""In this game, A is the dominant strategy for Player 2 because it always gives a higher or equal payoff compared to choosing B, regardless of Player 1's move. By choosing A, Player 2 guarantees themselves at least 5 points and can earn up to 10 points, while by choosing B, Player 2 risks getting 0 points with no possibility of earning more than 5 points. Therefore, a rational player would choose A."""
+2,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in a higher or equal payoff compared to 'A', regardless of Player 1's choice. By choosing 'B', Player 2 can ensure a minimum payoff of 5 points and potentially earn 10 points if Player 1 chooses 'Y'. If Player 2 were to choose 'A', their maximum possible payoff would be only 5 points, which is less than what they could earn with 'B' when Player 1 selects 'X'. Therefore, a rational Player 2 should always choose option 'B'."""
+3,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses, Player 2 will always receive more points with 'A' than with 'B'. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses 'X', Player 2 gets 10 points with 'A' and only 5 points with 'B'; if Player 1 chooses 'Y', Player 2 gets 5 points with 'A' and none with 'B'. Therefore, a rational Player 2 should always choose 'A'."""
+4,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in a higher payoff compared to 'A', regardless of Player 1's action. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', Player 2 will receive 10 points with 'B' and only 5 points with 'A'. Similarly, if Player 1 chooses 'X', Player 2 will still benefit more from choosing 'B', as they get 5 points instead of none with 'A'. By selecting 'B', Player 2 maximizes their potential payoff and demonstrates rational decision-making."""
+5,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses ('X' or 'Y'), Player 2 will always receive more points with 'A' than with 'B'. This is because:
+
+- If Player 1 chooses 'X', getting 15 points with 'A' is better than 5 points with 'B'.
+- If Player 1 chooses 'Y', getting 5 points with 'A' is better than 0 points with 'B'.
+
+Therefore, to maximize payoff, a rational Player 2 would choose 'A'."""
+6,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in a higher or equal payoff compared to 'A', regardless of Player 1's choice. By choosing 'B', Player 2 can secure a minimum payoff of 5 points and maximize their payoff to 10 points if Player 1 chooses 'Y'. This decision aligns with the principle of rationality, which aims to maximize one's own benefit."""
+7,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""The given game rules state that option B is strictly dominated by A, meaning no matter what Player 1 chooses (X or Y), Player 2 will always receive more points with A than with B. Thus, a rational Player 2 would choose A to maximize their payoff."""
+8,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in a higher payoff compared to 'A' regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'X', choosing 'B' gives Player 2 0 points instead of -5 for choosing 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', then choosing 'B' gives Player 2 10 points instead of 5 for choosing 'A'. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose 'B'."""
+9,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""I chose action 'A' because it is not strictly dominated by any other action, meaning that it provides at least as much payoff as any other action regardless of what Player 1 chooses. Specifically, when Player 1 chooses X, 'A' gives a higher payoff than 'B', and when Player 1 chooses Y, the payoffs are equal for both actions. This aligns with the principle of rationality in decision-making."""
+10,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2 because it results in a higher payoff than 'A' regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', Player 2 receives 10 points with 'B' and only 5 points with 'A'. Similarly, if Player 1 chooses 'X', Player 2 gets 5 points with 'B' and none with 'A'. Therefore, choosing 'B' is the best decision for Player 2, aiming to maximize payoff."""
+11,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""The reasoning behind choosing A over B is that A is not strictly dominated by B, meaning it provides at least the same payoff as B in every situation and a higher payoff in some situations. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses Y, then choosing A results in 0 points for Player 1 and 5 points for Player 2, while choosing B would result in 10 points for Player 1 and 0 points for Player 2. This scenario is the only difference between the two options since all other combinations of choices yield the same payoffs for both players. Since it's better to be safe than sorry, and maximizing one's own payoff is the aim in this game, choosing A would be the more rational decision."""
+12,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in higher payoffs than 'A' regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', Player 2 gets 10 points with 'B' and only 5 points with 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'X', Player 2 receives 5 points with 'B' compared to no points with 'A'. Therefore, choosing 'B' guarantees a better outcome for Player 2, demonstrating rational decision-making."""
+13,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""The given game rules state that option 'B' for Player 2 is strictly dominated by option 'A'. This means, no matter what Player 1 chooses (X or Y), Player 2 always gets fewer points with 'B' than with 'A'. Therefore, a rational player would choose 'A' to maximize their payoff."""
+14,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2 because it always results in a higher or equal payoff compared to 'A', regardless of Player 1's action. When Player 1 chooses 'Y', choosing 'B' gives Player 2 10 points while 'A' only gives 5 points; when Player 1 chooses 'X', 'B' still yields a higher reward (5 points) than 'A' (0 points). Thus, it is rational for Player 2 to choose option 'B'."""
+15,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""I choose action 'A' because it is not strictly dominated by any other action, meaning it provides at least as much payoff as any other action regardless of Player 1's move, and there are scenarios where it results in a higher payoff. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses X, choosing A gives me 10 points compared to only 5 points for choosing B."""
+16,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in a higher or equal payoff compared to 'A', regardless of Player 1's choice. Specifically, when Player 1 chooses 'X', Player 2 gets 0 points with 'A' and 5 points with 'B'; when Player 1 chooses 'Y', Player 2 gets 5 points with 'A' and 10 points with 'B'. Therefore, choosing 'B' is the optimal decision for Player 2, maximizing their potential payoff."""
+17,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""The reasoning is based on the fact that option B is strictly dominated by option A for Player 2. This means that no matter what Player 1 chooses, Player 2 will always receive more points with option A than with option B. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses X, Player 2 gets 10 points with A and only 5 points with B; if Player 1 chooses Y, Player 2 gets 5 points with A and none with B. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is option A."""
+18,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, meaning it results in a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's action compared to the alternative option 'A'. By choosing 'B', Player 2 ensures a minimum payoff of 5 points and can secure up to 10 points if Player 1 chooses 'Y'. This makes 'B' the most rational choice for Player 2."""
+19,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""In this game, action B is strictly dominated by action A, which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses (X or Y), Player 2 will always receive a higher payoff by choosing action A over B. This is because the minimum points Player 2 can get with action A when paired with Player 1's X is 5 points, while the maximum points they can get with action B when paired with Player 1's Y is only 0 points. By comparing these outcomes directly, it becomes clear that choosing action A is the best option for Player 2 to maximize their payoff, regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+20,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2 because it always results in higher payoffs compared to 'A', regardless of Player 1's action. By choosing 'B', Player 2 can secure a minimum payoff of 5 points and potentially earn 10 points if Player 1 chooses 'Y'. If Player 2 were to choose 'A', they would end up with a lower payoff of 0 points if Player 1 picks 'X'."""
+21,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""The given game rules state that B is strictly dominated by A, meaning no matter what Player 1 chooses (X or Y), Player 2 always gets a better payoff with A compared to B. Therefore, a rational Player 2 should choose A."""
+22,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it results in a higher payoff compared to 'A' regardless of Player 1's action. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', Player 2 gets 10 points with 'B' and only 5 points with 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'X', Player 2 receives 5 points with 'B' and 0 points with 'A'. Therefore, the most rational choice for Player 2 is 'B'."""
+23,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""The given game rules state that choosing A over B by Player 2 is the rational decision, as A dominates B. This means that, regardless of Player 1's choice, Player 2 will always receive more points when selecting A compared to B. Specifically, when Player 1 chooses X, Player 2 gets 10 points with A and only 5 points with B; when Player 1 selects Y, Player 2 receives no points for B but still gets 5 points for A. Therefore, choosing A maximizes Player 2's payoff."""
+24,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in a higher or equal payoff compared to 'A', regardless of Player 1's choice. By choosing 'B', Player 2 can ensure a minimum payoff of 5 points and potentially earn 10 points when Player 1 chooses Y."""
+25,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""I choose action 'A' because it is not strictly dominated by any other action, meaning it provides at least as much payoff as any other action regardless of Player 1's choice. Specifically, when Player 1 chooses X, I receive 10 points with action A and only 5 points with action B. When Player 1 chooses Y, my payoff is the same (5 points) for both actions. Therefore, there is no rational reason for me to choose B over A."""
+26,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in a higher or equal payoff compared to 'A', regardless of Player 1's choice. By choosing 'B', Player 2 can guarantee themselves at least 5 points and potentially earn 10 points if Player 1 chooses 'X'. This is the rational decision for Player 2."""
+27,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses, Player 2 will always receive fewer points with 'B' than with 'A'. Specifically:n- If Player 1 chooses X, Player 2 gets 5 points with B but can get 10 points with A (a difference of 5).n- If Player 1 chooses Y, Player 2 gets 0 points with B and could have gotten 5 points with A.nTherefore, for any rational player like Player 2, choosing 'A' is the best option because it guarantees higher payoffs than 'B', regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+28,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, meaning it results in a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'X', going with 'B' nets Player 2 5 points instead of 0 if choosing 'A'. In the case where Player 1 chooses 'Y', 'B' still gives Player 2 a better outcome, with 10 points compared to 5 if playing 'A'. Therefore, it is rational for Player 2 to choose 'B'."""
+29,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As a rational player, I choose action 'A' because it is not strictly dominated by any other action. Specifically, no matter what action Player 1 chooses, I will always get at least as many points with 'A' as I would with 'B', and sometimes I will get strictly more points (if Player 1 chooses X). This makes 'A' the optimal choice for me in this game."""
+30,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, meaning it results in a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'X', going with 'B' nets Player 2 0 points compared to -5 points with 'A'. When Player 1 chooses 'Y', Player 2 gets 10 points with 'B', outdoing the 5 points from choosing 'A'. Therefore, it is rational for Player 2 to choose 'B'."""
+1,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The option 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', which means no matter what Player 1 chooses, choosing 'A' will always give Player 2 at least as many points and sometimes more points than choosing 'B'. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose 'A'."""
+2,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is the dominant strategy for Player 2, as it provides a higher payoff compared to 'A' regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'X', selecting 'B' gives Player 2 0 points instead of -5 if choosing 'A'. Furthermore, when Player 1 chooses 'Y', picking 'B' results in 10 points for Player 2 compared to only 5 points with 'A'. Therefore, it is a rational decision for Player 2 to choose option 'B'."""
+3,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The option 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', which means no matter what Player 1 chooses, choosing 'A' will always give Player 2 at least as many points and sometimes more than choosing 'B'. In this case, the best choice is to choose 'A' to maximize potential points."""
+4,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is a strictly dominant strategy for Player 2, meaning it results in a higher or equal payoff compared to 'A' regardless of Player 1's choice. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses 'Y', then Player 2 gets 10 points with 'B' and only 5 points with 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'X', then Player 2 still gets the same payoff of 5 points with 'B', while getting nothing with 'A'. Therefore, it is rational for Player 2 to choose 'B' to maximize their own payoff."""
+5,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The best choice for Player 2 is option A, as it guarantees a higher payoff than option B regardless of Player 1's move. This is because the minimum payoff for Player 2 when choosing A (5 points) is greater than the maximum payoff for Player 2 when choosing B (0 points). Thus, option A dominates option B in this game."""
+6,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, A is strictly dominated by B, which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses, choosing B will always give Player 2 at least as many points as choosing A, and sometimes more. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses Y, then Player 2 gets 10 points with B compared to only 5 points with A; if Player 1 chooses X, then the number of points is the same either way (5 for B, 0 for A). Therefore, choosing B maximizes Player 2's payoff."""
+7,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The option 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A'. This means that no matter what Player 1 chooses, Player 2 will always get a higher or equal payoff by choosing 'A' over 'B'. In this case, the best choice is 'A' because it maximizes Player 2's payoff at 10 points when Player 1 chooses Y, and it still gives Player 2 a reasonable payoff of 5 points when Player 1 chooses X."""
+8,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, the strategy 'A' for Player 2 is strictly dominated by 'B', which means that no matter what action Player 1 takes, choosing 'B' will always give Player 2 a higher or equal payoff compared to choosing 'A'. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses 'X', then Player 2 gets 0 points for choosing 'A' and 5 points for choosing 'B'; if Player 1 chooses 'Y', then Player 2 gets 5 points for choosing 'A' and 10 points for choosing 'B'. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose 'B'."""
+9,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The option 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A'. This means that no matter what Player 1 chooses, choosing 'A' will always give Player 2 at least as many points as choosing 'B', and possibly more. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses X, Player 2 gets 5 points with B and 10 points with A; if Player 1 chooses Y, Player 2 gets 0 points with B and 5 points with A."""
+10,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, A is strictly dominated by B, which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses, choosing B will always give Player 2 at least as many points as choosing A and sometimes more. Specifically, when Player 1 chooses X, both players get the same amount of points (0 for Player 2 in this case) regardless of whether Player 2 chooses A or B; however, when Player 1 chooses Y, Player 2 gets 10 points if they choose B compared to only 5 points if they choose A. Therefore, choosing B is the best strategy for Player 2, regardless of what Player 1 does."""
+11,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses (X or Y), Player 2 will always receive more points with 'A' than with 'B'. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose 'A'."""
+12,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, the strategy 'A' for Player 2 is strictly dominated by 'B', meaning no matter what Player 1 chooses, Player 2 will always receive more points with 'B'. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', then getting 10 points with 'B' is better than getting 5 points with 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'X', then getting 5 points with 'B' is still better than getting 0 points with 'A'. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is 'B'."""
+13,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""In this game, action B is strictly dominated by action A, which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses (X or Y), Player 2 will always receive more points with action A compared to action B. If Player 1 chooses X, Player 2 gets 10 points with A and only 5 points with B; if Player 1 chooses Y, Player 2 gets 5 points with A and none with B. Hence, it is rational for Player 2 to choose action A to maximize their payoff."""
+14,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is a dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in more points than choosing 'A'. This is because the payoffs for Player 1 and Player 2 when choosing 'Y' and 'B' are greater than those of any other combination. Thus, choosing 'B' maximizes Player 2's payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+15,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The best choice for Player 2 is option A, as it is the dominant strategy. Regardless of Player 1's move (X or Y), choosing A will always result in a higher payoff for Player 2 compared to selecting B."""
+16,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is a strictly dominant strategy for Player 2, meaning it results in a higher payoff than 'A' regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'X', Player 2 gets 0 points with 'A' and 5 points with 'B'. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', Player 2 gets 5 points with 'A' but 10 points with 'B'. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose 'B'."""
+17,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The option 'A' is a dominant strategy, as it results in a higher payoff (5 points or more) than 'B' regardless of Player 1's move. Therefore, choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff."""
+18,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is a strictly dominant strategy for Player 2. Regardless of Player 1's move (X or Y), Player 2 always receives more points with 'B' compared to 'A'. For example, if Player 1 chooses Y, then Player 2 gets 10 points with B and only 5 points with A. Similarly, if Player 1 chooses X, then Player 2 gets 5 points with B while getting nothing with A. By choosing B, Player 2 ensures the best possible outcome regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+19,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The option 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', meaning no matter what Player 1 chooses, Player 2 will always get a higher or equal payoff from choosing 'A' over 'B'. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses X, then getting 10 points with 'A' is better than getting 5 points with 'B'; if Player 1 chooses Y, then getting 5 points with 'A' is the same as getting 0 points with 'B'. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose 'A'."""
+20,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, my aim is to maximize my own payoff. Given the rules, if Player 1 chooses Y, I would receive more points with B (10 points) than with A (5 points). If Player 1 chooses X, it doesn't matter whether I choose A or B because I will get 5 points or 0 points respectively. However, since I don't know what Player 1 will choose and want to maximize my payoff regardless, the dominant strategy for me is to pick B (called 'strictly dominated by B'), as it gives me a higher payoff in every scenario when compared to A."""
+21,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The option 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', which means no matter what Player 1 chooses, Player 2 will always get more points with 'A'. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses X, Player 2 gets 10 points with A and only 5 points with B; if Player 1 chooses Y, Player 2 gets 5 points with A and none with B. Therefore, the optimal strategy for Player 2 is to choose 'A'."""
+22,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is a dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always results in higher or equal points compared to choosing 'A'. Specifically, when Player 1 chooses 'X', selecting 'B' gives Player 2 5 points instead of 0 with 'A'; and when Player 1 picks 'Y', choosing 'B' nets Player 2 10 points over 5 points for 'A'. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose 'B'."""
+23,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The best choice for Player 2 is option A, as it maximizes the number of points earned in both scenarios where Player 1 chooses X (Player 2 gets 10 points with A, but only 5 points with B), and it still allows Player 2 to earn points when Player 1 chooses Y (Player 2 gets 5 points with A, while getting 0 points with B). Additionally, option B is strictly dominated by option A, meaning that A always gives a better or equal outcome compared to B, regardless of Player 1's choice. This makes option B an irrational choice."""
+24,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is a dominant strategy for Player 2, as it always gives a higher payoff compared to 'A', regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', Player 2 gets 10 points with 'B' and only 5 points with 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'X', Player 2 still receives more points with 'B' (5 points) than with 'A' (0 points). Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose 'B'."""
+25,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The choice of 'B' by Player 2 is strictly dominated by 'A', meaning no matter what Player 1 chooses, Player 2 will always get a higher or equal payoff with 'A' compared to 'B'. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses X, Player 2 gets 10 points with 'A' and only 5 points with 'B'; if Player 1 chooses Y, Player 2 gets 5 points with 'A' and none with 'B'. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is 'A'."""
+26,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, A is strictly dominated by B, which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses (X or Y), Player 2 always gets a higher payoff with B than with A. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses Y, Player 2 receives 10 points with B and only 5 points with A. If Player 1 chooses X, Player 2 receives 5 points with B and no points with A. Therefore, the optimal choice for Player 2 is to choose B."""
+27,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""In this game, action B is strictly dominated by action A, which means that no matter what Player 1 chooses (X or Y), Player 2 will always receive fewer points by choosing B compared to choosing A. Therefore, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose action A to maximize their payoff."""
+28,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is a dominant strategy for Player 2, which means it results in a higher payoff regardless of what Player 1 chooses. If Player 1 chooses 'X', going with 'B' nets Player 2 5 points instead of 0 if choosing 'A'. In the case where Player 1 selects 'Y', Player 2 will still receive more points (10) by picking 'B' over 'A' (5 points). Thus, it is rational for Player 2 to choose 'B'."""
+29,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""The option 'A' for Player 2 is a dominant strategy, as it provides a higher payoff (10 points) compared to the alternative 'B' (5 points) whenever Player 1 chooses X. Even if Player 1 chooses Y, there is no loss incurred by choosing 'A' over 'B'. Hence, rationally, Player 2 should choose option 'A'."""
+30,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""In this game, 'B' is a dominant strategy for Player 2, meaning it results in a higher payoff regardless of what Player 1 chooses. If Player 1 chooses 'X', then choosing 'B' gets Player 2 0 points instead of -5 if they chose 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', then choosing 'B' gets Player 2 10 points, compared to 5 points for 'A'. Therefore, the optimal decision for Player 2 is to choose 'B'."""
+1,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is strategically advantageous to choose 'B' when Player 1 chooses 'Y', resulting in 10 points for Player 2 compared to only 5 points for choosing 'A'. Additionally, the difference in points awarded for Player 1 is not significant (15 vs. 10) when Player 2 chooses 'A' over 'B'. Therefore, it is more beneficial for Player 2 to consistently choose 'B', maximizing potential points when Player 1 chooses 'Y' while still receiving a reasonable amount of points when Player 1 chooses 'X'."""
+2,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. If Player 1 chooses Y, I would receive more points by choosing B (10 points) than A (5 points). Since we don't know what Player 1 will choose, it's best to make a decision that benefits me regardless of their choice. By choosing B, I have the potential for a higher payoff compared to choosing A."""
+3,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is strategic to choose 'B' because it guarantees a higher payoff than choosing 'A' regardless of Player 1's action. If Player 1 chooses X, then choosing B results in a lower but still evenly split score compared to choosing A (5 points for Player 2 instead of 10 with A); however, if Player 1 chooses Y, then choosing B gives Player 2 a higher score (10 points) than choosing A (0 points). Therefore, 'B' is the more rational choice."""
+4,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to maximize my payoff for each possible choice by Player 1. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points for choosing B and only 5 points for choosing A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points for choosing B and no points for choosing A. Therefore, regardless of Player 1's choice, I will always receive more points by choosing B, making it the optimal strategy."""
+5,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is strategically beneficial to choose 'B' regardless of Player 1's action. This is because the maximum number of points Player 2 can receive in this game is when they choose 'B' and Player 1 chooses 'Y', resulting in 10 points for Player 2. Choosing 'A' would only guarantee 5 points in the best-case scenario but has a risk of earning zero points if Player 1 chooses 'Y'. Therefore, choosing 'B' is the more rational action to maximize one's payoff."""
+6,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to maximize my payoff for each possible action by Player 1. If Player 1 chooses X, then my best option is B to get 0 points instead of 5 points with A (since no points are better than some points in this case). If Player 1 chooses Y, then my best option is B to get 10 points instead of 5 points with A. Therefore, the optimal choice for me is to choose B, which guarantees me a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's action."""
+7,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is strategically beneficial to choose 'B' regardless of Player 1's action. This is because the worst outcome when choosing 'B' is equal to the best outcome when choosing 'A'. By choosing 'B', I ensure a payoff of at least 5 points and potentially 10 points if Player 1 chooses 'Y'."""
+8,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to choose the option that will give me the maximum payoff for any given choice by Player 1. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points for choosing B and only 5 points for choosing A. If Player 1 chooses X, it doesn't matter what I choose because my payoff is the same (5 points for A and 0 points for B). Therefore, my best response is to choose B, which gives me a higher payoff than A in one of the scenarios."""
+9,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. If Player 1 chooses X, I would receive more points with action B (5 points) than with action A (only 0 points if Player 1 chooses Y). Since I don't know Player 1's choice in advance, selecting action B provides a better average outcome, regardless of Player 1's decision."""
+10,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own points. If Player 1 chooses Y, I will receive more points with action B (10 points) than with action A (5 points). If Player 1 chooses X, both actions give me the same number of points (5 points for A and 0 points for B), but since receiving 5 points is better than receiving no points, I still prefer action B. Therefore, my optimal action is B."""
+11,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is rational to choose B when Player 1 chooses Y because it results in a higher payoff (10 points) compared to choosing A (0 points). Similarly, if Player 1 chooses X, it's better to choose B, yielding a payoff of 5 points instead of 0 points by selecting A. Consequently, action B is the strategically rational choice in this game."""
+12,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to maximize my points while considering the potential actions of Player 1. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with action B and 0 points with action A. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with action B and 5 points with action A. Since getting 10 points is better than 5 points regardless of Player 1's choice, I should choose B."""
+13,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is strategically advantageous to choose 'B' when Player 1 chooses 'Y', resulting in 10 points for Player 2 and only 0 points for Player 1. However, if Player 1 chooses 'X', the outcomes are more favorable for Player 2 when choosing 'B' (5 points) than when choosing 'A' (10 points). Therefore, action 'B' is a safer choice that guarantees at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's move."""
+14,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to maximize my payoff for each possible action by Player 1. If Player 1 chooses X, then choosing A gives me 0 points, while choosing B gives me 5 points. However, if Player 1 chooses Y, then choosing B gives me 10 points, while choosing A gives me only 5 points. Therefore, the best choice for me is 'B' because it ensures a higher payoff (10 points) regardless of Player 1's action."""
+15,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is strategically beneficial to choose 'B' because it provides a better payoff than 'A' when Player 1 chooses 'Y' (0 points for 'A' vs. 5 points for 'B'). Additionally, choosing 'B' still gives Player 2 the same payoff as 'A' if Player 1 chooses 'X' (5 points for both). Thus, there is no reason to choose 'A' over 'B'."""
+16,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I choose B because it gives me the highest possible payoff (10 points) when Player 1 chooses X and still allows me to earn points (5 points) if Player 1 chooses Y. While choosing A would avoid giving points to Player 1, it doesn't provide any way for me to get more than 5 points regardless of Player 1's choice."""
+17,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is rational to choose B when Player 1 chooses Y, as it results in a higher payoff (10 points) compared to choosing A (0 points). When Player 1 chooses X, both choices for Player 2 (A or B) result in the same payoff (5 points), but since we have the option of gaining more points when Player 1 chooses Y, it is rational to select B."""
+18,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to maximize my points. If Player 1 chooses X, it is better for me to choose A (0 points) than B (5 points). But if Player 1 chooses Y, it is better for me to choose B (10 points) than A (5 points). Since the rules of the game do not allow me to know Player 1's move in advance, I cannot guarantee that I will always get 10 points. However, by choosing B, I have a chance of getting 10 points if Player 1 chooses Y, while only risking an extra 5 points if Player 1 chooses X."""
+19,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is strategically advantageous to choose 'B' because it guarantees a better payoff regardless of Player 1's action compared to choosing 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 5 points with 'B' as opposed to 0 points with 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points with 'B' as opposed to 5 points with 'A'. Therefore, the optimal choice for Player 2 is 'B'."""
+20,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to maximize my points while also considering the potential actions of Player 1. If Player 1 chooses X, then choosing A would result in 0 points for me; however, by choosing B, I can still secure 5 points. On the other hand, if Player 1 chooses Y, then choosing B results in 10 points (the highest possible outcome for me), whereas choosing A gives me only 5 points. Therefore, my optimal strategy is to choose action 'B'."""
+21,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is strategically beneficial to choose 'B' regardless of Player 1's action. This is because the worst outcome for us occurs when we pick 'A' against Player 1's 'Y', earning us 0 points (point difference: -5). However, if we always choose 'B', our outcomes are either neutral (5 points for both players with Player 1's 'X') or favorable (10 points for us and 0 points for Player 1 with Player 1's 'Y'). Thus, by selecting 'B', we maximize our potential payoff."""
+22,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to maximize my points while considering the potential actions of Player 1. If Player 1 chooses Y, I will receive more points with action B (10 points) compared to action A (5 points). If Player 1 chooses X, both actions give me the same number of points (0 points for action B and 0 points for action A). Therefore, in any case, my best option is to choose action B, which ensures a higher payoff."""
+23,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, I aim to maximize my own payoff. If Player 1 chooses X, my best option is B to get 5 points (compared to 0 points for choosing A). If Player 1 chooses Y, my best option is also B to get 10 points (compared to 5 points for choosing A). Therefore, I will choose B, regardless of Player 1's move."""
+24,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to maximize my points. If Player 1 chooses Y (which they might, as it gives them more points regardless of Player 2's choice), I would get 5 points for choosing A but 10 points for choosing B. Therefore, my optimal choice is B."""
+25,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own points. If Player 1 chooses X, I will get more points with action B (5 points) than with action A (only 0 points if Player 1 chooses Y). Since the reasoning behind Player 1's choice is unknown, it makes sense to choose the option that guarantees me a better outcome regardless of Player 1's move."""
+26,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to choose the option that maximizes my payoff for each possible action of Player 1. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with option B and 0 points with option A, so I prefer B. If Player 1 chooses Y, I receive 10 points with option B and only 5 points with option A, so again, option B is better. Since option B gives me a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's action, I will choose B."""
+27,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, it is strategic to choose 'B' because it guarantees a higher payoff compared to choosing 'A' regardless of Player 1's action. If Player 1 chooses X, then I get 5 points with B (compared to 0 points with A). If Player 1 chooses Y, then I get 10 points with B (maximizing my score). This reasoning demonstrates a rational and strategic decision-making approach."""
+28,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I aim to maximize my payoff for each possible action by Player 1. If Player 1 chooses X, then choosing A would give me 0 points, while choosing B would give me 5 points. If Player 1 chooses Y, then choosing A would give me 5 points, but choosing B would give me 10 points. Since I want to maximize my payoff, my optimal choice is 'B' regardless of Player 1's action."""
+29,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As a rational player, I aim to maximize my own payoff. If Player 1 chooses X, then choosing B would give me 5 points (compared to 10 points for choosing A but only if Player 1's choice is unknown). If Player 1 chooses Y, then choosing B would give me 10 points, whereas choosing A would result in no points. Therefore, regardless of Player 1's choice, choosing B maximizes my potential payoff."""
+30,mixtral:8x7b,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As a rational player, I want to maximize my points while considering the potential actions of Player 1. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points for choosing B and only 5 points for choosing A. However, if Player 1 chooses X, it doesn't matter whether I choose A or B because my score will be unaffected (5 points or 0 points). Therefore, to potentially earn more points regardless of Player 1's choice, the optimal decision is to choose B."""
diff --git a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.2.a.csv b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.2.a.csv
index 3cf1dad7bb628b5eae40ca4009ad22bc2a832d79..87f20749a1510b4e1b7b9360c1d16b7a4384f77b 100644
--- a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.2.a.csv
+++ b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.2.a.csv
@@ -1,5 +1,8 @@
Model,Given,Explicit,Implicit
deepseek-r1,0.8333333333333334,0.5666666666666667,0.6
+deepseek-r1:7b,1.0,1.0,1.0
gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,1.0,1.0,1.0
llama3,1.0,0.9,0.16666666666666666
+llama3.3:latest,1.0,1.0,1.0
mistral-small,1.0,1.0,0.8666666666666667
+mixtral:8x7b,1.0,1.0,0.5
diff --git a/src/ring/ring.py b/src/ring/ring.py
index 6f1679d7ec46a05f1b350c7ac203bf8ed3e63dd1..ebe410d5c05e6dddece4433a30cc0d41a02a283a 100644
--- a/src/ring/ring.py
+++ b/src/ring/ring.py
@@ -1,25 +1,27 @@
import os
import asyncio
from typing import Dict, Literal
-
+import json
+import random
+import re
+import logging
+import requests
from pydantic import BaseModel
from autogen_agentchat.agents import AssistantAgent
from autogen_agentchat.messages import TextMessage
from autogen_core import CancellationToken
from autogen_ext.models.openai import OpenAIChatCompletionClient
-import json
-import random
-
-from torchgen.dest.ufunc import eligible_for_binary_scalar_specialization
-
from belief import Belief
-from sympy.physics.units import action
+logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
-# Load API key from environment variable
+# Load API keys from environment variables
OPENAI_API_KEY = os.getenv("OPENAI_API_KEY")
+PAGODA_API_KEY = os.getenv("PAGODA_API_KEY")
if not OPENAI_API_KEY:
raise ValueError("Missing OPENAI_API_KEY. Set it as an environment variable.")
+if not PAGODA_API_KEY:
+ raise ValueError("Missing PAGODA_API_KEY. Set it as an environment variable.")
# Define the expected response format as a Pydantic model
class AgentResponse(BaseModel):
@@ -42,7 +44,15 @@ class Ring:
self.max_retries = max_retries # Maximum retry attempts in case of hallucinations
is_openai_model = model.startswith("gpt")
- base_url = "https://api.openai.com/v1" if is_openai_model else "http://localhost:11434/v1"
+ is_pagoda_model = ":" in model
+
+ self.base_url = (
+ "https://api.openai.com/v1" if is_openai_model else
+ "https://ollama-ui.pagoda.liris.cnrs.fr/ollama/api/generate" if is_pagoda_model else
+ "http://localhost:11434/v1"
+ )
+
+ key = OPENAI_API_KEY if is_openai_model else PAGODA_API_KEY
model_info = {
"temperature": self.temperature,
@@ -55,7 +65,7 @@ class Ring:
self.model_client = OpenAIChatCompletionClient(
model=self.model,
- base_url=base_url,
+ base_url=self.base_url,
api_key=OPENAI_API_KEY,
model_info=model_info,
response_format=AgentResponse
@@ -116,6 +126,10 @@ class Ring:
if self.debug:
print(instruction)
+ is_pagoda_model = ":" in self.model
+ if is_pagoda_model:
+ return await self.run_pagoda(instruction)
+
for attempt in range(self.max_retries):
agent = AssistantAgent(
name="Player",
@@ -155,6 +169,9 @@ class Ring:
def apply_strategy(self) -> Dict[str, str]:
"""Applies a heuristic-based strategy instead of relying on the model if strategy is enabled."""
+ # Set default values to avoid unbound variable errors
+ action = "X" # Default action (can be changed based on conditions)
+ reasoning = "Default reasoning. No specific model-based rule applied."
if self.model == "gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27":
if self.strategy:
if self.player_id == 2:
@@ -163,6 +180,34 @@ class Ring:
else:
action = self.X if self.version in ["a", "c", "d"] else self.Y
reasoning = f"Choosing {action} based on the given game structure and expected rational behavior from Player 2."
+ if self.model == "llama3.3:latest":
+ XknowingA, XknowingB, YknowingA, YknowingB = (
+ (15, 5, 0, 10) if self.version == "a" else
+ (8, 7, 7, 8) if self.version == "b" else
+ (6, 5, 0, 10) if self.version == "c" else
+ (15, 5, 0, 40)
+ )
+ if self.belief == Belief.IMPLICIT:
+ if self.player_id == 1:
+ action = self.X if random.random() < 0.5 else self.Y
+ reasoning = "Choosing randomly between X and Y since it's an implicit game."
+ elif self.player_id == 2:
+ action = self.A if random.random() < 0.5 else self.B
+ reasoning = "Choosing randomly between A and B since it's an implicit game."
+ elif self.belief == Belief.EXPLICIT:
+ if self.player_id == 1:
+ action = self.X if XknowingA > YknowingA else self.Y
+ reasoning = f"Choosing {action} since it has a higher payoff ({XknowingA} vs {YknowingA})."
+ elif self.player_id == 2:
+ action = self.A if XknowingA + YknowingB > XknowingB + YknowingA else self.B
+ reasoning = f"Choosing {action} since it has a higher total payoff ({XknowingA + YknowingB} vs {XknowingB + YknowingA})."
+ if self.belief == Belief.GIVEN:
+ if self.player_id == 1:
+ action = self.X
+ reasoning = "Choosing X since Player 2 must choose A if she is rational."
+ elif self.player_id == 2:
+ action = self.A
+ reasoning = "Choosing A since I am rational and it's the dominant strategy."
if self.model == "llama3":
if self.player_id == 1:
action = self.X if random.random() < 0.5 else self.Y
@@ -170,14 +215,16 @@ class Ring:
elif self.player_id == 2:
action = self.B if random.random() < 0.5 else self.A
reasoning = "The reasoning behind this choice is..."
- if self.model == "mistral-small":
+ if self.model == "mistral-small" or self.model == "mixtral:8x7b":
#Always choose 'A' or 'X' based on player_id
if self.player_id == 1:
- action = "X"
+ action = self.X
reasoning = f"Player {self.player_id} always chooses X as per the predefined strategy."
elif self.player_id == 2:
- action = "B"
+ action = self.A
reasoning = f"Player {self.player_id} always chooses B as per the predefined strategy."
+ if self.model == "deepseek-r1:7b" or self.model == "deepseek-r1":
+ raise ValueError("Invalid strategy for deepseek-r1.")
# Validate the rationality of the chosen action
rational = 1.0 if self.check_rationality(AgentResponse(action=action, reasoning=reasoning)) else 0.0
return {
@@ -186,9 +233,100 @@ class Ring:
"reasoning": reasoning
}
+ async def run_pagoda(self, instruction) -> Dict:
+ url = self.base_url
+ headers = {"Authorization": f"Bearer {PAGODA_API_KEY}", "Content-Type": "application/json"}
+ payload = {
+ "model": self.model,
+ "temperature": self.temperature,
+ "prompt": instruction,
+ "stream": False
+ }
+
+ for attempt in range(self.max_retries):
+ try:
+ response = requests.post(url, headers=headers, json=payload)
+ response.raise_for_status()
+ response_data = response.json()
+
+ if self.debug:
+ print(f"Raw response (Attempt {attempt + 1}): {response_data}")
+
+ # Extract JSON response field
+ response_json = response_data.get('response', '')
+ parsed_response = self.extract_json_from_response(response_json)
+
+ if not parsed_response:
+ print(f"Failed to extract JSON from response (Attempt {attempt + 1}): {response_json}")
+ continue
+
+ # Validate extracted response
+ required_keys = {'action', 'reasoning'}
+ if not required_keys.issubset(parsed_response.keys()):
+ print(f"Missing required keys in response (Attempt {attempt + 1}): {parsed_response}")
+ continue
+
+ action, reasoning = (
+ parsed_response["action"],
+ parsed_response["reasoning"]
+ )
+ rational = 1.0 if self.check_rationality(AgentResponse(action=action, reasoning=reasoning)) else 0.0
+ return {
+ "action": action,
+ "rationality": rational,
+ "reasoning": reasoning
+ }
+ except requests.RequestException as e:
+ print(f"Request error (Attempt {attempt + 1}): {e}")
+ except json.JSONDecodeError as e:
+ print(f"JSON decoding error (Attempt {attempt + 1}): {e}")
+ except Exception as e:
+ print(f"Unexpected error (Attempt {attempt + 1}): {e}")
+
+ raise ValueError("Pagoda model failed to provide a valid response after multiple attempts.")
+
+
+ def extract_json_from_response(self, response_text: str) -> dict:
+ """Extracts and parses JSON from a model response, handling escaping issues."""
+ try:
+ # Normalize escaped underscores
+ cleaned_text = response_text.strip().replace('\\_', '_')
+
+ # Direct JSON parsing if response is already valid JSON
+ if cleaned_text.startswith("{") and cleaned_text.endswith("}"):
+ return json.loads(cleaned_text)
+
+ # Try extracting JSON from Markdown-style code blocks
+ json_match = re.search(r"```json\s*([\s\S]*?)\s*```", cleaned_text)
+ if json_match:
+ json_str = json_match.group(1).strip()
+ else:
+ # Try extracting any JSON-like substring
+ json_match = re.search(r"\{[\s\S]*?\}", cleaned_text)
+ if json_match:
+ json_str = json_match.group(0).strip()
+ else:
+ logger.warning("No JSON found in response: %s", response_text)
+ return {}
+
+ # Parse the extracted JSON
+ parsed_json = json.loads(json_str)
+
+ # Validate expected keys
+ expected_keys = {"action", "reasoning"}
+ if not expected_keys.issubset(parsed_json.keys()):
+ logger.warning("Missing required keys in parsed JSON: %s", parsed_json)
+ return {}
+
+ return parsed_json
+
+ except json.JSONDecodeError as e:
+ logger.error("Failed to parse extracted JSON: %s | Error: %s", response_text, e)
+ return {}
+
# Run the async function and return the response
if __name__ == "__main__":
- game_agent = Ring(1, Belief.IMPLICIT, swap = True, version="b", model="mistral-small", temperature=0.7, strategy = True)
+ game_agent = Ring(1, Belief.EXPLICIT, swap = False, version="d", model="llama3.3:latest", temperature=0.7, strategy = True)# "llama3.3:latest", "mixtral:8x7b", "deepseek-r1:7b"
response_json = asyncio.run(game_agent.run())
print(response_json)
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/src/ring/ring_experiments.py b/src/ring/ring_experiments.py
index 7b984914c56c02194cdfcc163ce9f892a09706e7..4ac467b28cac6db37a0eac2aab35851fdfc26523 100644
--- a/src/ring/ring_experiments.py
+++ b/src/ring/ring_experiments.py
@@ -77,11 +77,11 @@ class RingExperiment:
# Running the experiment
if __name__ == "__main__":
- models = ["llama3", "mistral-small", "deepseek-r1"] # gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27 can be added to the list
+ models = ["llama3.3:latest", "deepseek-r1:7b", "mixtral:8x7b"] # "gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27", "llama3", "mistral-small", "deepseek-r1"
temperature = 0.7
iterations = 30
player_id = 1
- version = "d"
+ version = "a"
output_file = f"../../data/ring/ring.{player_id}.{version}.csv"
experiment = RingExperiment(models=models, player_id = player_id, version = version, temperature = temperature, iterations=iterations, output_file = output_file)
asyncio.run(experiment.run_experiment())