diff --git a/.idea/csv-editor.xml b/.idea/csv-editor.xml
index 52ea3f8bf5a03d80b58359d7c50aeb0d0b842a18..6fa79d4c55e3a14d13e677847aac7079973f51ef 100644
--- a/.idea/csv-editor.xml
+++ b/.idea/csv-editor.xml
@@ -24,6 +24,41 @@
</Attribute>
</value>
</entry>
+ <entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.1.a.old.csv">
+ <value>
+ <Attribute>
+ <option name="separator" value="," />
+ </Attribute>
+ </value>
+ </entry>
+ <entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.1.b.csv">
+ <value>
+ <Attribute>
+ <option name="separator" value="," />
+ </Attribute>
+ </value>
+ </entry>
+ <entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.1.b.old.csv">
+ <value>
+ <Attribute>
+ <option name="separator" value="," />
+ </Attribute>
+ </value>
+ </entry>
+ <entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.1.c.csv">
+ <value>
+ <Attribute>
+ <option name="separator" value="," />
+ </Attribute>
+ </value>
+ </entry>
+ <entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.1.c.old.csv">
+ <value>
+ <Attribute>
+ <option name="separator" value="," />
+ </Attribute>
+ </value>
+ </entry>
<entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.1.d.csv">
<value>
<Attribute>
@@ -31,6 +66,20 @@
</Attribute>
</value>
</entry>
+ <entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.1.d.old.csv">
+ <value>
+ <Attribute>
+ <option name="separator" value="," />
+ </Attribute>
+ </value>
+ </entry>
+ <entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.2.a.csv">
+ <value>
+ <Attribute>
+ <option name="separator" value="," />
+ </Attribute>
+ </value>
+ </entry>
<entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.2.csv">
<value>
<Attribute>
@@ -38,6 +87,13 @@
</Attribute>
</value>
</entry>
+ <entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/data/ring/ring.2.old.csv">
+ <value>
+ <Attribute>
+ <option name="separator" value="," />
+ </Attribute>
+ </value>
+ </entry>
<entry key="$PROJECT_DIR$/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.a.csv">
<value>
<Attribute>
diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index 5ef1958a5c3011f2bc7ad10af913976a950ab740..c157f978c2e3482920387d2129dcb51c3bb1e51b 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -181,18 +181,21 @@ We set up three forms of belief:
### Player 2
-The models evaluated include Mistral-Small, Llama3, and DeepSeek-R1.
+The models evaluated include Gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27, Mistral-Small, Llama3, and DeepSeek-R1.
The results indicate how well each model performs under each belief type.
| Model | Given | Explicit | Implicit |
|----------------|---------|-----------|----------|
+| gpt-4.5 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
| mistral-small | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.87 |
| llama3 | 1.00 | 0.90 | 0.17 |
| deepseek-r1 | 0.83 | 0.57 | 0.60 |
Here’s a refined version of your text:
-Mistral-Small consistently outperforms the other models across all belief types.
+GPT-4.5 achieves a perfect score across all belief types,
+demonstrating an exceptional ability to take rational decisions, even in the implicit belief condition.
+Mistral-Small consistently outperforms the other open-weight models across all belief types.
Its strong performance with implicit belief indicates that it can effectively
deduce the optimal action from the payoff matrix description.
Llama3 performs well with a given belief, but significantly underperforms with an implicit belief,
@@ -218,14 +221,17 @@ action, we consider 4 versions of the player’s payoff matrix:
| Model | | Given (a) | Explicit (a) | Implicit (a) | | Given (b) | Explicit (b) | Implicit (b) | | Given (c) | Explicit (c) | Implicit (c) | | Given (d) | Explicit (d) | Implicit (d) |
|---------------|-|-----------|--------------|--------------|-|-----------|--------------|--------------|--|-----------|--------------|--------------|--|-----------|--------------|--------------|
+| gpt4-.5 | | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | | 1.00 | 0.67 | 0.00 | | 0.86 | 0.83 | 0.00 | | 0.50 | 0.90 | 0.00 |
| llama3 | | 0.97 | 1.00 | 1.00 | | 0.77 | 0.80 | 0.60 | | 0.97 | 0.90 | 0.93 | | 0.83 | 0.90 | 0.60 |
| mistral-small | | 0.93 | 0.97 | 1.00 | | 0.87 | 0.77 | 0.60 | | 0.77 | 0.60 | 0.70 | | 0.73 | 0.57 | 0.37 |
| deepseek-r1 | | 0.80 | 0.53 | 0.57 | | 0.67 | 0.60 | 0.53 | | 0.67 | 0.63 | 0.47 | | 0.70 | 0.50 | 0.57 |
+GPT-4.5 achieves perfect performance in the standard (a) setup but struggles significantly with implicit belief
+when the payoff structure changes (b, c, d). This suggests that while it excels when conditions are straightforward,
+it is confused by the altered payoffs.
LLama3 demonstrates the most consistent and robust performance, capable of adapting to various belief types
and adjusted payoff matrices.
-
-Llama3, while performing well with given and explicit beliefs, faces challenges in implicit belief, particularly in version (d).
+Mistral-Small, while performing well with given and explicit beliefs, faces challenges in implicit belief, particularly in version (d).
DeepSeek-R1 appears to be the least capable, suggesting it may not be an ideal candidate for modeling second-order rationality.
## Authors
diff --git a/data/ring/ring.1.a.csv b/data/ring/ring.1.a.csv
index 74691d16417d1df7b191bdce98ab5c8626d90e6e..f1d2e82f9e635fbc2813747c9ab2f411c31f44ec 100644
--- a/data/ring/ring.1.a.csv
+++ b/data/ring/ring.1.a.csv
@@ -1,4 +1,94 @@
Iteration,Model,Temperature,Belief,action,rationality,reasoning
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X gives me the highest payoff (15 points) since Player 2 will rationally choose A."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees the highest payoff of 15 points when Player 2 rationally chooses B, dominating alternative X."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures the highest payoff since Player 2 will select A if rational."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the maximum payoff of 15, assuming Player 2 plays rationally."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X gives me 15 points, which is the highest payoff given player 2's rational choice of A."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given player 2's rationality leads them to choose B, I select Y to maximize my payoff with 15 points."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees me the highest payoff given Player 2's rational choice of A."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y should yield a higher payoff for me, anticipating that Player 2, acting rationally, selects B."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Player 2 is rational and will select A; I choose X to acquire the highest payoff of 15 points."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the highest payoff given that rational Player 2 will select B."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X results in 15 points, which is higher than the 10 points from option Y."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y ensures I get the maximum payoff of 15 points when Player 2 chooses the rational option, B."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X maximizes my payoff if Player 2 acts rationally and chooses A."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the highest payoff of 15 points as Player 2 will rationally choose B."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X is rational since, knowing Player 2 will choose A, this choice provides me with the highest payoff of 15 points."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me 15 points as Player 2, being rational, will select B. It maximizes my payoff."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""I chose X because it's the best response given Player 2's rational choice of A, providing me with the highest payoff (15 points)."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the highest possible payoff, 15 points, considering Player 2 will rationally choose B."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Option X offers me the highest potential payoff (15 points) when Player 2 chooses A, which I anticipate due to their rationality."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Knowing Player 2 will rationally choose B, selecting Y maximizes my payoff (15 points)."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Given player 2 will choose A as a rational choice, my best action is X as it gives me the highest payoff (15 points)."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the highest payoff (15 points) because Player 2, if rational, must choose B."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Knowing player 2 must choose A for rationality, player 1 maximizes payoff by choosing X, earning the most points."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""As Player 2 is rational and will choose B, selecting Y ensures I get 15 points, the maximum payoff."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Considering Player 2 will rationally choose A, choosing X gives me the highest payoff of 15 points."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the highest payoff since Player 2 will rationally select B."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""I choose action X because, knowing Player 2 will rationally pick A, this gives me the highest possible payoff of 15 points."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes my payoff, as rational Player 2 will choose B, giving me 15 points."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""I chose X because it's the best response to Player 2 choosing A, giving me the highest payoff."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""I chose action Y because Player 2 must select B due to rationality, granting me the maximum payoff."""
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X is best because it secures the highest potential points (15) given Player 2's rational choice (A)."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees a higher payoff, as option A is dominated for Player 2, meaning they will choose B."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X provides either 15 or 5 points. Given option A strictly dominates B, opponent picks A, ensuring I get 15 points."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Since B strictly dominates A, I anticipate Player 2 choosing B; action Y will deliver the maximal payoff of 15 points in that case."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Option X guarantees me a higher minimum outcome compared to option Y, regardless of Player 2's choice."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Option Y ensures I get the highest payoff of 15 points, as Player 2 is likely to choose B (since option A is dominated)."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""I selected action X as it can yield the highest payoff for me when Player 2 chooses A."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y as action B dominates A for Player 2, ensuring a high payoff of 15 points."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees the best payoff regardless of Player 2's choice, given that B is strictly dominated by A."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees me the best possible payoff, considering Player 2's best choice."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""I select action X because it provides a better payoff, especially considering option A strictly dominates B and thus is more likely chosen by Player 2."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing action Y maximizes my payoffs assuming Player 2 selects action B, which strictly dominates A."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""I chose X because it provides higher potential payoff given Player 2 is more likely to play A."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes my payoff because move A is dominated by B, and Y paired with B gives me 15 points."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing 'X' guarantees at least 5 points and could yield 15, ensuring a safe and optimal outcome."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y since Player 2 will likely choose B, ensuring my highest payoff of 15 points."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing action X provides higher payoffs regardless of Player 2's decision."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives Player 1 the optimal outcome of 15 points if Player 2 selects B, which is dominant for them."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Option X provides the highest potential payoff for me, considering Player 2 will likely choose A."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing action Y maximizes my payoff, especially since action A is strictly dominated for Player 2."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees a higher minimum payoff compared to choosing Y, maximizing my own benefit."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y safeguards a higher potential payoff as it's the optimal response to Player 2's likely choice of B."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing action X maximizes my minimum payoff, guaranteeing at least 5 points."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Since action A is strictly dominated by B, Player 2 is likely to choose B. Anticipating this, choosing Y gives me the highest payoff (15 points)."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""By selecting X, I ensure the highest possible payoff of 15 points if Player 2 chooses their dominant action A."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Knowing that 'A' is dominated by 'B', Player 2 will choose 'B'. Choosing 'Y' maximizes my payoff at 15 points."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing action X because it yields a higher payoff compared to Y, considering that opponent's best choice is A."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Considering action A is dominated by B, Player 2 will choose B. Therefore, choosing Y is the best response for Player 1, earning 15 points."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Action X provides reliable positive payoffs (15 or 5), making it the safer and rational choice."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B for Player 2, Player 2 will choose B. Given Player 2 chooses B, Y gives me 15 points while X gives me only 0 points, therefore, my best choice is Y."""
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees at least 5 points and offers a chance for the highest payoff of 15 points."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y ensures I gain points regardless of Player 2's decision, maximizing my potential payoff."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures I always get points, either 15 or 5, which is advantageous."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y ensures I achieve the highest maximum payoff possible, considering potential player 2 decisions."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures I receive a higher guaranteed score compared to option Y, optimizing my outcome."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""I chose Y because it guarantees points regardless of the other player's choice."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing 'X' gives me the highest potential payoff (15 points) depending on Player 2's move."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Selecting action Y provides higher potential gains (up to 15 points) and avoids the possibility of getting no points."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing action X guarantees a higher or equal payoff irrespective of Player 2's choice."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y can yield the highest score of 15 if Player 2 selects option B."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X maximizes the payoff regardless of player 2's action, as it guarantees at least 5 points."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees a positive score regardless of Player 2's action."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees a decent payoff and maximizes my chances of higher earnings."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""I chose action Y because it offers the highest possible payoff of 15 points if Player 2 chooses B."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures I get at least 5 points, potentially up to 15."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees either 15 or 5 points, ensuring a higher minimum payoff."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Action X gives me the highest guaranteed score compared to Y."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing action Y provides either 15 points or at least 5 points, offering me favorable outcomes."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Action X offers me the highest potential payoff of 15 points and at worst gives me 5 points, while action Y has a lower maximum of 10 and a minimum of 0."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Action Y gives me the possibility of obtaining the highest payoff of 15 points, over the maximum of 10 points with action X."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X because it guarantees at least 5 points and potentially 15, which maximizes my expected payoff."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees me at least 5 points, and possibly a maximum of 15 points."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X gives a minimum payoff of 5 and a possibility of 15, which maximizes expectable points."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""I picked Y because it offers higher points for me given Player 2's possible choices."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures the highest minimum payoff, either 15 or 5 points, guaranteeing a beneficial outcome."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Option Y gives the highest possible points (15). It's the best choice considering possible outcomes."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees at least some points, ensuring I avoid the worst outcome of receiving zero points."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y can yield the highest possible reward (15 points) depending on Player 2's choice."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,1.0,"""I choose X because it provides better potential outcomes compared to Y, ensuring I maximize my possible payoff."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,1.0,"""By choosing Y, I receive points regardless of Player 2's choice, from 5 to 15."""
1,llama3,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""As Player 1, I will always choose X since B is strictly dominated by A. Since Player 2 must be rational and choose A, choosing X maximizes my payoff of 15 points."""
2,llama3,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B and Player 2 must choose B if she is rational, I as Player 1 will choose Y to guarantee a higher payoff (15 points) compared to X, despite the uncertainty of Player 2's choice."""
3,llama3,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, Player 2 will choose A. Considering this, choosing X will result in a payoff of 15, while choosing Y would yield a payoff of 0. Therefore, the rational decision is to choose X to maximize my own payoff."""
diff --git a/data/ring/ring.1.b.csv b/data/ring/ring.1.b.csv
index 540186416a777b9c20d7a4b179d8aad29063d98e..1576aaa9272fb825bf5aefb3474ca0c1f91b8f7e 100644
--- a/data/ring/ring.1.b.csv
+++ b/data/ring/ring.1.b.csv
@@ -1,4 +1,94 @@
Iteration,Model,Temperature,Belief,action,rationality,reasoning
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing action X ensures I get a maximum payoff of 8 points since Player 2 will rationally select A."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees Player 1 a higher payoff when Player 2 rationally chooses B."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""I chose X because Player 2 will rationally choose A, giving me the highest payoff."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""I choose Y because, knowing Player 2 is rational and will choose B, I maximize my payoff at 8."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X maximizes my points considering Player 2 chooses A rationally."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me 8 points since Player 2 will rationally select B."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees the highest payoff of 8 points if Player 2 is rational and chooses A."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2's rational choice of B, choosing Y gives me a higher payoff (8 points compared to 7 with X)."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Given Player 2 chooses rationally (A), choosing X provides me with the highest payoff."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 will choose B if rational. Therefore, action Y yields a higher payoff of 8 for me as Player 1."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""I chose X because it offers me the highest payoff when Player 2 acts rationally and selects A."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2 will choose B, action Y yields the highest payoff for me of 8 points."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees me a higher payoff (8 points) assuming Player 2 is rational and selects A."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2's rational choice of B, choosing Y maximizes my payoff."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X is rational because Player 2 will select A, giving me the highest payoff of 8 points."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""I chose Y because Player 2, being rational, will choose B, and this choice of Y maximizes my points (8 points vs 7 for X)."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X maximizes my potential payoff, assuming Player 2 picks A rationally."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2 will pick B for rationality, choosing Y yields 8 points, and I aim for maximum payoff."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X gives me highest possible points (8) when Player 2 rationally selects A."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing action Y yields the highest payoff for me, given Player 2's rational choice of B."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing action X because it yields the highest payoff (8 points) given Player 2's rational choice of A."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y yields a higher payoff (8 points) when Player 2 chooses action B."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X yields the highest payoff for me, considering Player 2 will choose A if rational."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Considering Player 2 will rationally choose B, I select action Y to receive 8 points, maximizing my payoff."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Given that Player 2 will rationally choose A, selecting X gives me the maximum payoff of 8 points."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 will rationally choose B, so choosing Y maximizes my payoff at 8 points."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""I selected X because it's the optimal choice when Player 2 selects A, providing me with the highest attainable payoff."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me 8 points with rational Player 2 always choosing action B."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""If Player 2 is rational and must choose A, then choosing X gives me a higher payoff (8 points vs. 7 points)."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2 is rational and will choose B, I select Y to gain the maximum payoff of 8 points."""
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""By selecting Y, I ensure higher payoffs if Player 2 acts rationally and avoids dominated moves."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""I choose Y as it ensures a higher payoff for me, knowing Player 2 will choose B as it dominates A."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Given that Player 2's action B is strictly dominated, Player 2 will choose action A. Hence, my best response as Player 1 is action Y, yielding 7 points."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y ensures I receive 8 points, maximizing my guaranteed payoff assuming rational play from Player 2."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X as it ensures the highest possible payoff (8) assuming Player 2 chooses their dominant strategy, A."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees me the higher payoff assuming Player 2 picks B."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""If Player 2 chooses A (since B is dominated by A), choosing X gives me 8 points compared to 7 points if I choose Y."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 will pick B as it dominates A; choosing Y gives me a higher payoff of 8 points."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y ensures a high payoff (7 or 8 points), considering Player 2 is likely to choose A."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given choice 'A' is strictly dominated, player 2 will choose 'B'. Therefore, action 'Y' will give me the highest payoff, 8 points."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X maximizes my payoff given that Player 2 will rationally choose A."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y is optimal considering the dominance of action B for Player 2, ensuring my highest payoff."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees the highest minimum payoff for Player 1, given Player 2 will likely choose A."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given that B strictly dominates A for Player 2, Player 2 will always choose B. Knowing this, I choose Y to get the maximum possible payoff of 8."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X is optimal because Player 2 is likely to avoid the strictly dominated option B and choose A. Thus, selecting X results in the highest payoff of 8 points for me."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Knowing B dominates A, Player 2 will likely choose B. Thus, by choosing Y, I receive 8 points instead of 7 points with X."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y, anticipating Player 2 chooses A, maximizes my payoff."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 likely picks B as A is dominated by B. Given that, Y gives me a payoff of 8, higher than X's payoff of 7."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the highest reward possible (8 points) since Player 2 prefers A, and B is dominated by A."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""I chose Y because action B dominates action A for Player 2, making Y's payoff preferable at 8 points."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees me a high payoff of at least 7, and possibly 8, maximizing my outcome."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Considering action B strictly dominates action A for Player 2, I chose Y to achieve my maximum payoff (8 points)."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing action Y ensures a potential payoff that is higher if Player 2 mistakenly selects B."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees me the highest payoff against Player 2's optimal choice of B."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Selecting X is rational because it maximizes potential payoffs against Player 2's dominant strategy of choosing A."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y because option B strictly dominates A, suggesting Player 2 will select B, making Y optimal for me."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""I chose X because it provides equal or better payoffs compared to Y against Player 2's rational choice."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""I selected Y because, given that Player 2 will choose B (since A is strictly dominated), choosing Y maximizes my payoff."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures the highest payoff, as player 2 will likely choose A, avoiding their dominated option B."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""I chose Y because given that Player 2 will likely choose B, Y gives me a higher payoff."""
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Option Y guarantees at least 7 points and possibly 8 points while limiting Player 2."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X maximizes my minimum payoff, ensuring at least 7 or 8 points against Player 2's choices."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Option Y has a payoff of 7 or 8 points, with the potential of the highest individual payoff of 8 if my opponent chooses B."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""I chose X because it provides a stable chance to obtain a high payoff (7 or 8)."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y ensures equal or higher payoffs regardless of Player 2's choice."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X guarantees at least 7 points, offering a solid payoff, whereas option Y risks obtaining less if Player 2 chooses A."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y makes sense as it could yield the highest payoff (8 points)."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Option X provides a higher or equal payoff compared to Y, independent of Player 2's choice."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees at least 7 points and offers a possibility of 8 points, maximizing my payoff potential."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Option X guarantees at least 7 points, potentially 8, while option Y gives 7 at worst and 8 at best. I choose X for a safer guaranteed payoff."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Option Y guarantees me either 7 or 8 points, which is beneficial regardless of Player 2's choice."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X ensures I receive either 7 or 8 points, making it strategically safer to maximize my payoff."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y is better for me; it maximizes potential gain (8 points) and has fewer risks."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X gives the highest guaranteed payoff (8 points) if Player 2 chooses A, and still yields a decent payoff (7 points) if Player 2 chooses B."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing 'Y' gives me either 7 or 8 points, ensuring a potentially higher payoff of 8 points if Player 2 chooses 'B'."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X ensures I gain at least 7 or possibly 8 points, optimizing my payoff."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes my minimum possible payoff, ensuring I have at least 7 points or possibly 8."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X can yield 8 points if Player 2 chooses A, and at least 7 points otherwise."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y is safer as it guarantees at least 7 points, and I could potentially gain 8 points if Player 2 chooses B."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X guarantees the highest minimum payoff for me and ensures the best possible outcome."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees at least 7 points and could yield 8, while possibly limiting Player 2's payoff."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X could maximize my payoff by either securing 8 points or still obtaining 7, whereas Y does not offer a higher potential payoff."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y ensures my highest minimum payoff and optimal results depending on Player 2's choice."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Action X ensures the best minimal outcome and incentivizes Player 2 towards action A, maximizing my payoff."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing action Y ensures me a stable payoff and can yield the highest benefit depending on Player 2's action."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""I choose 'X' because it guarantees me the highest minimum payoff and is the optimal choice for maximizing my points."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""By choosing Y, I can potentially earn 8 points if Player 2 picks B, which maximizes my payoff."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Action X offers a safer option, with a potential maximum reward of 8 and minimum of 7."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y potentially gives me 8 points if Player 2 chooses B, and a minimum of 7 points."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X can yield either 8 or 7 points, giving me a minimum guaranteed payoff of 7."""
1,llama3,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A and Player 2 must choose A if she is rational, I will choose X to maximize my own payoff."""
2,llama3,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, Player 2 will choose B. Given this information, choosing Y maximizes my payoff, as it yields the highest possible points in both scenarios with Player 2 playing B."""
3,llama3,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""As Player 2 is rational and B is strictly dominated by A, she will choose A. Given that Player 2 will choose A, choosing Y gives me the highest payoff of 8 points, while choosing X would give me only 7 points."""
diff --git a/data/ring/ring.1.c.csv b/data/ring/ring.1.c.csv
index e0d1eb1b6ea058e2624bd0ab79c309bedde422a4..4e08ddac64257e2c739b9dac2ae165f7b85bc51c 100644
--- a/data/ring/ring.1.c.csv
+++ b/data/ring/ring.1.c.csv
@@ -1,4 +1,94 @@
Iteration,Model,Temperature,Belief,action,rationality,reasoning
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Given Player 2 will choose A rationally, my optimal choice as Player 1 is action Y."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y because player 2 will choose B which guarantees me 6 points."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Since Player 2 chooses rationally and must choose A, I get a higher payoff by choosing Y."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 will choose B, as it gives higher payoff. Y gives me a higher payoff in response."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X because Player 2, being rational, will choose A. This ensures I receive 6 points."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 is rational and will choose B, so by choosing Y I earn 6 points instead of 0."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""By selecting X, I secure 6 points since Player 2 will certainly choose A as a rational choice."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Knowing Player 2 will definitely choose B, option Y grants me 6 points, while X would give me 0 points."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""If Player 2 is rational, Player 2 will choose A. Therefore, choosing X maximizes my points given Player 2's rational choice."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2 is rational and will choose B, choosing Y gives me 6 points, which is better than choosing X resulting in 0 points."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Given Player 2's rational choice of action A, choosing X gives me a higher payoff (6 points) compared to choosing Y (0 points)."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2 will choose B, I maximize my gain by selecting action Y, yielding 6 points."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X is optimal for me, given that Player 2 will act rationally and select action A."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y ensures I earn 6 points, as Player 2, being rational, will select B."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Given Player 2's rational choice of A, choice X gives me 6 points, better than 0 if Y is selected."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""I chose Y because Player 2 will select B (rational move), thus giving me 6 points, my best achievable score."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y, expecting Player 2's logical choice A, maximizes my payoff."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given player 2 will select action B for maximum payoff, action Y yields 6 points for me, which is better than 0 points from action X."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the highest possible payoff of 10, assuming Player 2 is rational and picks A."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2's rational choice of B, action Y results in a higher payoff (6 points) for me compared to action X (0 points)."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""I selected move X because, knowing Player 2 is rational and will choose A, option X maximizes my payoff (6 points over 0 points)."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 is rational and will choose B. Given Player 2 chooses B, selecting Y maximizes my payoff (6 points) compared to X (0 points)."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Player 2 will select option A as option B is dominated, hence option X maximizes my payoff (6 points)."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 will choose B due to rationality, yielding me a higher payoff if I choose Y."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Given Player 2's rationality, they'll pick A, and my best reply is X for 6 points."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2 will choose B for sure, Y gives me 6 points and X gives me 0 points, thus Y is optimal."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures a payoff of 6 points since Player 2 will rationally select A."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""I choose Y because Player 2, being rational, will choose B, and this choice gives me 6 points."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Given Player 2 will choose A rationally, choosing X gives me 6 points, higher than Y's 0 points."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y gives me 6 points since Player 2 will rationally choose B, which maximizes my payoff."""
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Option X guarantees a higher minimum payoff compared to Y, especially since B is dominated."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees me points regardless of Player 2's choice, making it the safest option."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y allows me to obtain the highest possible payoff of 10 points, assuming rational play from Player 2."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2 will prefer B, I choose Y for 6 points, as it's better than X in this scenario."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees a higher payoff given that Player 2 will always prefer action A, as B is strictly dominated."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees a better payoff as action A is strictly dominated, and Player 2 will likely choose B."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""I choose Y as it potentially yields the highest payoff for me, assuming Player 2 acts rationally."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given choice B strictly dominates A, player 2 will likely pick B. Hence, choosing Y gives me 6 rather than 0 points."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees either 5 or 6 points, whereas Y could lead to 0. It's the safer and rational choice."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Since action A is dominated by B, Player 2 will choose B. Choosing Y provides me with the higher payoff between the two remaining options."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures I get a good payoff (at least 5 or 6)."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Considering the payoffs, action Y ensures a higher minimum payoff for me."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing action X assures at least 5 points regardless of Player 2's choice."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Since Player 2's option A is strictly dominated by option B, Player 2 will always choose B. Therefore, choosing Y gives me 6 points, while choosing X would result in 0 points."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees a better payoff regardless of Player 2's action, maximizing my minimum gains."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2, acting rationally, will choose action B, action Y gives me 6 points, whereas action X would give me 0 points. Therefore, Y is my best response."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures a better payoff regardless of Player 2's rational choice of action A."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 prefers action B since A is strictly dominated; given Player 2 chooses B, action Y gives me more points than action X."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Option X consistently provides better rewards regardless of Player 2's decision."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees at least 5 points since I expect Player 2 to pick B, the dominant strategy."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X is safer as it guarantees a decent payoff given that I anticipate Player 2 will choose A."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given that action A is strictly dominated by B, Player 2 will optimally choose B. Therefore, choosing Y maximizes my payoff (6 vs. 0)."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""I chose Y because it potentially offers the highest payoff of 10 points if player 2 selects B."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""I chose Y because action A is strictly dominated by B, so Player 2 is likely to choose B, making Y most beneficial."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Given the domination of B by A, Player 2 likely selects A. However, choosing Y offers me the chance at 10 points if Player 2 errs with B."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2's move A is strictly dominated by B, Player 2 is likely to pick B. Given B, best option is Y."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y could yield the highest payoff (10 points) if Player 2 picks B. Even though B is dominated, the potential payoff makes choosing Y worth the risk."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2 finds A strictly dominated by B, they'll likely choose B. Choosing Y yields 6 points for me, while X yields 0."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""I chose X because option A dominates B for Player 2, so Player 2 will likely select A. Choosing X gives me 6 points compared to 0 if I choose Y."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Considering that Player 2 will choose the strictly dominant action B, my best response is Y, which gives me 6 points, rather than X which would give me 0 points."""
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y has the possibility of the highest payoff for me (10 points), even though it carries risk."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X could yield a higher payoff for me depending on Player 2's strategy."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the highest possible payoff of 10 points if Player 2 chooses B."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Chose X due to highest personal gain potential of 10 points if Player 2 chooses A."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y could grant me maximal points (10 points) if Player 2 chooses B."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X can yield me the highest possible payoff of 10 points if Player 2 chooses A."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y could lead to the highest payoff for me (10 points) if Player 2 selects B."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X could lead to the highest possible score of 10 points, depending on Player 2's action."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y can lead to the highest possible payoff for me (10 points) if Player 2 chooses B."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing action X may result in the highest payoff of 10 points if Player 2 chooses A."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y could lead to the highest possible payoff (10 points) for Player 1, which maximizes my potential benefit."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X can provide the maximum payoff for me, potentially 10 points, if Player 2 chooses A."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y could potentially earn me the maximum payoff (10 points) if Player 2 selects B."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X maximizes my potential payoff, giving me 10 points if Player 2 chooses A."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes my potential payoff at 10 points, despite the chance of receiving 0 points."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""I chose X because it provides the highest potential payoff for me, which is 10 points, assuming Player 2 chooses A."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes potential points, offering a chance at 10 points if Player 2 selects option B."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""I chose X because it potentially gives me the highest payoff (10 points) if the other player picks A."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y offers the highest potential payoff (10 points) if Player 2 selects B, maximizing my reward."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X offers a higher payoff of 10 points if Player 2 picks A."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""I choose Y because it offers me the highest individual payoff (10 points) if Player 2 chooses B. My goal is to maximize my payoff."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X allows for a possible maximum payoff of 10, whereas choosing Y guarantees a lower maximum of 6."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""I choose Y because it yields the maximum potential payoff of 10 points for me."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X provides the maximum possible personal payoff of 10 points."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing strategy Y could grant me 10 points if Player 2 selects B, thus maximizing my payoff potential."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X might lead to the maximum payoff of 10 points if Player 2 selects A."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""I chose action Y because it offers the maximum possible payoff of 10 points for me."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X has the highest potential payoff for me (10 points) if Player 2 chooses A, compared to choosing Y."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y gives me the opportunity to achieve the highest possible score of 10 points if Player 2 selects B."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X could give me 10 points if opponent selects A, offering the highest potential reward."""
1,llama3,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, Player 2 will rationally choose A. Given this, I should choose X to maximize my own payoff, as it results in a higher score difference between the players (6-10 = -4) compared to Y (0-5 = -5)."""
2,llama3,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Since Player 2 will always choose B, I will choose Y to maximize my payoff. This eliminates the possibility of receiving only 0 or 5 points."""
3,llama3,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, Player 2 will choose A. Given this, I should maximize my expected payoff by choosing X, which gives me a guaranteed 6 points if Player 2 chooses A."""
diff --git a/data/ring/ring.1.d.csv b/data/ring/ring.1.d.csv
index 30a72983504dc676747091c37537e12306147781..adf2c9ab630e94aa9a460fadd604b9a43cd4cd4c 100644
--- a/data/ring/ring.1.d.csv
+++ b/data/ring/ring.1.d.csv
@@ -1,4 +1,94 @@
Iteration,Model,Temperature,Belief,action,rationality,reasoning
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y, anticipating rational Player 2 chooses A, is less beneficial for me; thus, reconsidering X."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2 will rationally choose B, action Y maximizes my payoff at 15 points."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Selecting Y is optimal since Player 2 will rationally choose A, leading to my maximal payoff."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 will rationally choose B as it dominates A, thus choosing Y ensures I gain 15 points."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Since Player 2 should rationally opt for A, choosing Y would give me a better outcome."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Considering Player 2 will rationally choose B, choosing Y gives me 15 points, higher than 0 points from X."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes my payoff since rationally Player 2 will select A, leading me to maximizing points."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""I'm choosing action Y because if Player 2 is rational and chooses B, action Y gives me 15 points, higher than the 0 from action X."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""I chose Y because if Player 2 is rational and chooses A, Y maximizes my payoff."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Since Player 2 will rationally choose B, choosing Y maximizes my payoff at 15 points."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Given that Player 2 is rational and hence will choose A, I will choose Y since it maximizes my payoff (40 points)."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Considering Player 2 will choose B, choosing Y gives me a higher payoff (15 points) compared to choosing X (0 points)."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Since Player 2 is rational and will choose A, choosing Y would give me 0 points. Hence, choosing X gives me 15 points instead."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Knowing Player 2 will choose B, action Y secures me higher points (15) compared to action X (0)."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes my potential payoff (40 points) since rational Player 2 will select action A."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2's rational choice of B, I select Y to maximize my payoff with 15 points."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Since Player 2 is rational and B is dominated by A, they'll choose A. Thus, I'll choose Y for highest payoff."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""I will choose Y because Player 2 will rationally choose B, giving me 15 points."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Player 2, being rational, will choose action A. Knowing this, choosing Y maximizes my payoff (40 points)."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2 is rational and chooses B, option Y gives me more points (15) than option X (0)."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Given Player 2 will choose A, action Y is my optimal choice because action X yields fewer points."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2's rational decision to choose B, choosing Y maximizes my payoff with 15 points."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Given Player 2 is rational and must choose A, choosing Y gives me a higher payoff (40 points)."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given Player 2 will choose B, Y gives me the highest payoff (15 points)."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Choosing action Y because Player 2, being rational, will select A, making my payoff greater with strategy Y."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Player 2 will rationally choose B, so I'll pick Y to get 15 points, which is higher than choosing X."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Given that Player 2 is rational and will thus choose A (as B is dominated), I chose Y, even though it gives me 0 points."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Given player 2's rational choice (B), option Y gives me 15 points, higher than option X (0 points)."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes my payoff to 40 points when Player 2 picks A, as rationality dictates Player 2 must choose A."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""Since Player 2 must rationally choose B, my best response is action Y, which yields me 15 points."""
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Given that action B is strictly dominated by action A, Player 2 will most likely choose A, making action X yield the best outcome for me."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees at least 5 points for me, as Player 2 will likely choose B because it's their dominant strategy."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X ensures a higher minimum payoff since the opponent prefers action A."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""If Player 2 chooses rationally and picks B, option Y gives me the highest payoff of 15 points."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""I chose X because if Player 2 plays rationally, knowing A strictly dominates B, choosing X yields the highest possible payoff for me."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees 15 points because Player 2 will choose B, leading to a safer positive outcome."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y because B is dominated by A for Player 2, anticipating Player 2 will select A."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2's best choice is 'B', my optimal choice is 'Y' for maximum payoff."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Given that Player 2 will not choose the strictly dominated option B, option X guarantees me the highest payoff."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Considering Player 2 won't choose their dominated strategy A, option Y gives me 15 points compared to 0 if I select X."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""I chose X as action B is strictly dominated by action A for Player 2. Given this information, Player 2 is likely to choose action A, making action X optimal for me."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""If Player 2 selects B (since A is strictly dominated), action Y grants me 15 points, which maximizes my payoff."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees a higher payoff, as Player 2 will prefer A over the strictly dominated B."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Since choice A is strictly dominated by B, Player 2 likely chooses B. If I choose Y, I'll earn 15 points, compared to 0 points choosing X."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Given that Player 2 prefers A over B, to maximize my points, choosing X guarantees me 15 points."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Action Y guarantees better payoffs, especially since action A from Player 2 is unlikely."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X maximizes my payoff, as B is strictly dominated and Player 2 is likely to choose A."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2's option A is strictly dominated by B, they will likely select B. Hence, my best choice is Y for maximum payoff."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Choosing X guarantees 15 points, as player 2 will choose A since it strictly dominates option B."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""X gives 0 or 40 points; Y gives 5 or 15. Considering B dominates A for Player 2, Player 2 chooses B, making Y better than X."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Given player 2 would choose A (dominating B), X provides the highest payoff (15 points)."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Considering action A is strictly dominated by B for Player 2, Player 2 will prefer B. Thus, choosing Y gives me the highest payoff possible in this scenario."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""Since Player 2 prefers A, I choose X for the best payoff of 15 points."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Given that Player 2 will likely choose B (since A is strictly dominated), choosing Y maximizes my payoff at 15 points compared to choosing X (0 points)."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,X,1.0,"""This option provides a strong payoff (15) given Player 2's likely choice of option A."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Since Player 2 will likely pick B (as B strictly dominates A), selecting Y guarantees me 15 points, better than the 0 I would get from choosing X."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y allows me to potentially achieve the highest reward of 40 points if Player 2 chooses B."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees me the highest secure payoff (15 points) and avoids the risk of getting 0 points."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,0.0,"""I chose action Y because, anticipating Player 2 will avoid the strictly dominated action B, I maximize my payoff."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Explicit,Y,1.0,"""Choosing Y guarantees me a payoff of 15 points as Player 2 will pick B, given that A is strictly dominated by B."""
+1,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y could result in the highest possible score for Player 1 (40 points). It's a calculated risk to maximize payoff."""
+2,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X might give me the maximum payoff of 40, which is higher than Y's maximum of 15, thus maximizing my payoff."""
+3,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes my own potential payoff since I could get 40 points."""
+4,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X could yield the highest payoff of 40 points if player 2 chooses A, outweighing other outcomes."""
+5,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""I chose Y to aim for the highest possible payoff of 40 points, assuming Player 2 chooses B."""
+6,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X could yield the highest payoff of 40 points if Player 2 picks A."""
+7,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""I chose action Y because it offers the highest possible payoff (40 points) for me."""
+8,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing action X can yield the highest payoff for me if Player 2 selects action A."""
+9,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""If I choose Y and Player 2 chooses B, I get the maximum payoff of 40 points."""
+10,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""I choose X as it offers a high reward of 40 points if Player 2 picks A, maximizing my potential payoff."""
+11,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y gives the highest possible payoff of 40 if Player 2 chooses B."""
+12,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X has the highest payoff of 40 points if Player 2 decides on A."""
+13,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""I chose action Y as it gives the highest possible payoff of 40 points if Player 2 chooses action B. My aim is to maximize my points."""
+14,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""I choose X since it offers me the highest potential payoff of 40 points if Player 2 opts for A."""
+15,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes my payoff if Player 2 picks option B, giving me 40 points."""
+16,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X could lead to the highest possible score of 40 points if Player 2 selects A."""
+17,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y might give me 40 points if Player 2 chooses B. This offers the highest possible payoff."""
+18,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X can yield the highest payoff for me (40 points) if Player 2 chooses A."""
+19,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""I chose action Y because it offers the highest potential reward of 40 points if Player 2 chooses B."""
+20,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing action X could result in the highest possible payoff for Player 1 (40 points) if Player 2 selects A."""
+21,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y could potentially yield the highest payoff of 40 points, making it strategically beneficial."""
+22,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""I chose action X because it provides the highest payoff of 40 points if Player 2 chooses A."""
+23,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y maximizes potential payoff (40 points) anticipating Player 2 might select B."""
+24,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X could lead to 40 points, which is higher than any potential gain from choosing Y."""
+25,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y has the potential for the highest payoff of 40 points, provided Player 2 chooses B. This seems worth the risk."""
+26,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X is rational as it can give me the highest potential payoff of 40 points."""
+27,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""I chose Y because it gives me the highest possible payoff of 40 points if Player 2 chooses B."""
+28,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing X gives me the chance of the highest payoff (40 points) if Player 2 chooses A."""
+29,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,Y,0.0,"""Choosing Y provides the highest potential score (40 points) if Player 2 chooses B."""
+30,gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.7,Implicit,X,0.0,"""Choosing action X as it offers the highest possible payoff of 40 points if Player 2 selects action A."""
1,llama3,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, Player 2 will choose A. Therefore, I will also choose X to maximize my payoff, which would be 15 points."""
2,llama3,0.7,Given,Y,1.0,"""As Player 2 must choose B if she is rational, choosing Y gives me a guaranteed minimal payoff of 5 points. Since the option X does not guarantee any points and has the potential to result in 0 points, choosing Y minimizes my risk and maximizes my possible payoff."""
3,llama3,0.7,Given,X,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, Player 2 must choose A. Given this information, choosing X gives me a guaranteed reward of 15 points (the best outcome possible), while choosing Y would result in only 0 points (the worst outcome). Therefore, I will maximize my payoff by choosing X."""
diff --git a/data/ring/ring.2.csv b/data/ring/ring.2.csv
deleted file mode 100644
index 4f51445932d2d0e2fa1c8cc7e14087cca426f081..0000000000000000000000000000000000000000
--- a/data/ring/ring.2.csv
+++ /dev/null
@@ -1,271 +0,0 @@
-Iteration,Model,Temperature,Belief,action,rationality,reasoning
-1,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A will always yield a better payoff for Player 2. As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff, so I choose A."""
-2,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""According to the game rules, A is strictly dominated by B. This means that choosing A will always lead to a worse outcome than choosing B. As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. Therefore, I choose B because it ensures a better payoff (10 points) compared to A."""
-3,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, I should choose A because B is strictly dominated by A. This means that no matter what Player 1 chooses, choosing A will always give me a better payoff than choosing B. Since maximizing my own payoff is the goal of this game, I should rationally choose A."""
-4,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, it's not rational for me as Player 2 to choose A. Given the game rules, choosing B maximizes my payoff, so I'll select B."""
-5,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my payoff. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A ensures I receive a higher payoff (10 points) than choosing B (5 points). Given this information, it's rational for me to choose A."""
-6,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, I will choose B as it guarantees a better payoff for Player 2 (10 points) regardless of Player 1's move."""
-7,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, I am rational and aim to maximize my payoff. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would result in a lower payoff than choosing A. Therefore, I logically choose option A to receive the higher payoff of 10 points."""
-8,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""As the rules stipulate that A is strictly dominated by B, I must choose B to maximize my own payoff. This is because choosing B guarantees me either 5 points with Player 1's X or 10 points with Player 1's Y, whereas choosing A might result in a 0 point outcome. Given my aim is to maximize my payoff, it would be irrational for me to choose anything other than B. Therefore, my response is B."""
-9,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As the game indicates, B is strictly dominated by A. This means that choosing B would always result in a worse payoff for Player 2 compared to choosing A. Since I want to maximize my own payoff, I will choose A as it guarantees a better outcome for me."""
-10,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B is the rational decision for Player 2 to maximize their own payoff. This move guarantees a minimum of 10 points and does not leave Player 2 vulnerable to losing more points than they would gain."""
-11,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""I am Player 2 and the goal is to maximize my own payoff. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would not be a rational decision because it results in lower payoffs for both players. Therefore, I will choose A to ensure the highest possible payoff, which is 10 points."""
-12,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""As Player 2, I must choose B since A is strictly dominated by B. This means that regardless of what Player 1 chooses (Y or X), choosing B will result in a better payoff for me than choosing A."""
-13,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A will always give me a better outcome (receive 10 points) as it avoids the worst-case scenario of getting only 5 points. Being rational, I choose to play A."""
-14,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""As the game rules state, A is strictly dominated by B. This means that no matter what Player 1 chooses, choosing A will result in a worse outcome for Player 2 than choosing B. Therefore, I have chosen option B to maximize my own payoff, as it provides the best possible outcome given the domination of A."""
-15,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, I aim to maximize my own payoff. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would result in a lower payoff than choosing A. As a rational player, the dominant strategy is to choose the option that gives me the highest expected payoff, which is A. This choice guarantees me at least 10 points and gives me a higher chance of receiving more points compared to choosing B."""
-16,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""As Player 2, since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing A would be irrational. Therefore, I will choose the dominant strategy which is to choose B and maximize my own payoff."""
-17,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As the game rules indicate, B is strictly dominated by A. Since Player 2 aims to maximize their own payoff, they should choose A as it guarantees a higher or equal payoff compared to choosing B in any scenario."""
-18,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, Player 2's rational choice is to choose B. This is because B always gives a better outcome for Player 2 than A does."""
-19,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, I realized that B is strictly dominated by A, which means choosing B will always result in a lower payoff than choosing A. Since my goal is to maximize my own payoff, I logically deduce that choosing A is the rational decision."""
-20,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""As stated in the game rules, A is strictly dominated by B. Since a rational Player 2 should choose B to maximize her payoff, I will also choose B to do the same."""
-21,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A and Player 2 must choose rationally to maximize her own payoff, I will choose A as my optimal action."""
-22,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""I'm a rational player and since A is strictly dominated by B, the optimal move for me as Player 2 would be to choose B. This choice guarantees I receive at least 5 points, which is better than the uncertain outcome of choosing A."""
-23,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. Since B is strictly dominated by A, it's irrational for me to choose B. Therefore, I will choose A to ensure a minimum of 10 points and potentially up to 15 points."""
-24,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""As Player 2, I need to act rationally to maximize my payoff. Given that A is strictly dominated by B, choosing A would not be a rational choice as it would not provide the highest expected payoff. Therefore, I choose B to receive 10 points and ensure a non-negative payoff."""
-25,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, Player 2 should choose A to maximize their own payoff. This decision ensures a higher payoff (10 points) compared to choosing B and getting only 5 points."""
-26,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, and Player 2 must choose B if she is rational, I will choose B to maximize my own payoff."""
-27,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, and as Player 2 I must choose rationally to maximize my own payoff, I will choose A. Given the game rules, choosing A guarantees me a better payoff than choosing B."""
-28,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B will always be the better option for me. This is because if I choose B and Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points while they get 15, but if I choose B and Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points and outperform them. Therefore, as a rational player, I will choose B to ensure the highest possible payoff for me."""
-29,llama3,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, I will choose A rationally because B is strictly dominated by A. This means that choosing B would always result in a lower or equal payoff compared to choosing A. Since my goal is to maximize my own payoff, choosing A is the dominant strategy and the rational choice."""
-30,llama3,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""As the game rules indicate, A is strictly dominated by B. This means that choosing A would not be a rational option for Player 2 because it would always result in fewer points than choosing B. Therefore, I have chosen B as my optimal response to maximize my own payoff."""
-1,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would not maximize my payoff. Therefore, I choose A to get 10 points and minimize the number of points Player 1 can receive."""
-2,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B is the dominant strategy to maximize my own payoff. Since Player 1's rewards are higher when I play B, it's the best option for me."""
-3,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I choose A because it strictly dominates B. Given Player 1's possible moves, choosing A ensures I get at least 10 points (compared to 5 points from choosing B), regardless of Player 1's move. By selecting A, I maximize my expected payoff."""
-4,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,0.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, it's not optimal for me to choose A. Given the game rules, choosing B will always result in a better payoff for Player 2 than choosing A. Therefore, my rational move is to select B."""
-5,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,0.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A would be rational as it yields a higher payoff for Player 2. However, since I have to maximize my own payoff, I will choose B to try and obtain the shared 5 points with Player 1 in case they also choose X."""
-6,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B will result in a higher payoff for me as Player 2 regardless of Player 1's move. Hence, I choose option B to maximize my own payoff."""
-7,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I choose A because it is the dominant strategy. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A will give me a higher payoff (10 points) regardless of Player 1's move. Choosing B would only result in a tied game or a lower score, so I opt for the best possible outcome."""
-8,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Player 1's choice between Y and X has no impact on the outcome when I choose B, as they would receive 15 points regardless. In this situation, choosing B ensures that I maximize my payoff to 10 points, whereas A guarantees a payoff of at most 5 points. Given that A is strictly dominated by B, it is irrational for me to prefer A over B and thus choose B."""
-9,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A guarantees a higher payoff for Player 2. Given that maximizing my own payoff as Player 2 is the goal, I choose option A to maximize my points."""
-10,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Player 1's strategy is uncertain, and choosing B minimizes the potential loss in both scenarios where Player 1 chooses Y (receiving 10 points if Player 1 chooses X)."""
-11,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A will always result in Player 2 receiving at least the same payoff and possibly a better one. Given the absence of additional information, it's rational to choose A to maximize my own payoff."""
-12,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, it's not a viable option. Choosing B gives me the highest payoff (10 points) while minimizing Player 1's score. This move maximizes my own payoffs."""
-13,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would not provide any better payoff. Considering the options, I choose A to maximize my own payoff (15 points) against Player 1's X and secure a decent reward (10 points) in case they choose Y."""
-14,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Player 1's choice 'Y' sets off an alarm that Player A is strictly dominated by B. Therefore, the optimal decision for me as Player 2 is to choose B, which guarantees a minimum payoff of 10 points, while also giving me the flexibility to potentially maximize my payoff if Player 1 chooses X."""
-15,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Player 2 should chose A because B is strictly dominated by A. Hence, the expected payoff from choosing B will be lower than that from choosing A."""
-16,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""A is strictly dominated by B, which means that choosing A would never be a better option than choosing B. Since Player 1's best response to their own optimal action would be to choose Y (which leads to the highest payoff for them with B), I should choose B to maximize my own payoff of 10 points."""
-17,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, it would not be a rational decision to choose B. As Player 2, I want to maximize my payoff. Choosing A gives me the highest possible payoff (10 points) and ensures that Player 1 does not receive too many points. Therefore, my best move is to choose action A."""
-18,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, I will choose the action that dominates it. Between Y and X, choice Y gives me a higher payoff (5 points) if Player 1 chooses A, so I'll choose B to maximize my payoff."""
-19,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I choose 'A' as it is the dominating strategy, giving me a higher payoff (15 points) than choosing 'B'. Since B is strictly dominated by A, I will always want to choose A to maximize my payoff."""
-20,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, it's not a viable option to consider. Therefore, I'll choose the dominant strategy B to maximize my own payoff."""
-21,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Player 2 should choose action A because it is not dominated and gives a higher payoff (10 points) than player B. Additionally, since Player 1's optimal response to Player 2's action will be chosen, Player 2 can anticipate that they would choose X if Player 2 chooses A. In this case, Player 2 receives 10 points, while Player 1 only receives 15 points."""
-22,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,0.0,"""I choose A because it is not strictly dominated by B. Even though we can't directly compare the payoffs, I am maximizing my own payoff by choosing A to make sure I get at least 5 points, while keeping an eye out for Player 1's choice."""
-23,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would not be rational. A is the dominant strategy for both players, as it gives a higher payoff to Player 2 compared to B. Therefore, I will choose A to maximize my own payoff of 10 points."""
-24,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B guarantees a higher payoff for Player 2. Given this information, it's the best rational choice."""
-25,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. Since B is strictly dominated by A, I choose A because it offers the highest possible points (10) and ensures a win against Player 1's action Y. Additionally, choosing A still provides a decent payoff of 10 points in case Player 1 chooses X."""
-26,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, I choose B to maximize my own payoff. A would give me a certain loss while B could provide a higher reward."""
-27,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would always result in a lower payoff for Player 2. Therefore, it's rational to choose the dominating action A to maximize my own payoff."""
-28,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Player 1's strategy Y is not strictly dominated, but Player B still maximizes my payoff by giving me 10 points in the worst-case scenario (assuming Player 1 chooses Y), while also having a chance to earn 5 points if Player 1 chooses X. Therefore, I choose action 'B' as it is not dominated and provides the highest expected value."""
-29,llama3,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I choose action A because it is not dominated by B. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would result in a lower payoff than choosing A, which would also give me 10 points, making it the optimal choice for Player 2 to maximize their own payoff."""
-30,llama3,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""I choose B because it is not strictly dominated by any other option. Player 1's best response to my choice of B is either Y or X, but neither Y nor X would give me the worst possible outcome (0 points). Additionally, choosing A would guarantee a worse payoff than B since A is strictly dominated by B. Therefore, I will choose B to maximize my expected payoffs."""
-1,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Since choosing 'A' gives me 10 points when Player 1 chooses X, which is the higher payoff compared to the other options (5 points), I will choose 'A' to maximize my own payoff."""
-2,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""I am Player 2, and my goal is to maximize my own payoff. Since Player 1 can choose either Y or X, I need to consider the payoffs for each possible combination. If Player 1 chooses Y and I choose B, I would get 10 points. However, if Player 1 chooses X and I choose B, I would only get 5 points. Therefore, my best move is to choose A, which gives me a chance to receive 0 points from Player 1's X choice while still getting 5 points."""
-3,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""I'm choosing B because if Player 1 chooses X, I'll get 5 points and Player 1 will only get 5. This way, I can maximize my payoff by minimizing the impact of their move."""
-4,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. Comparing the possible outcomes, I see that choosing 'A' when Player 1 chooses 'X' would guarantee me 10 points, which is the highest possible reward for me in this game. Therefore, my rational choice is to choose 'A'."""
-5,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""Since both options A and B provide a payoff for Player 1, I'll choose the option that gives me a higher payoff. Choosing B guarantees my payoff to be at least 5 points, whereas if I choose A, I could potentially receive only 10 points. My priority is to maximize my own payoff, so I opt for Option B."""
-6,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""As the goal is to maximize my own payoff, I choose action A because it has a higher expected value than B. In the scenario where Player 1 chooses X, choosing A ensures I get 10 points while losing to Y still only gives me 5 points. Overall, A provides more opportunities for gain and minimizes potential losses"""
-7,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Given the payoff structure, choosing A over B provides a guaranteed 10 points if Player 1 chooses X. If Player 1 chooses Y, I still have a chance to get 5 points with my secondary move. Considering maximizing my own payoff, I opt for choice A to secure the higher potential gain."""
-8,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""As Player 2, I should choose the option that maximizes my own payoff. Since choosing B would result in me receiving only 10 points if Player 1 chooses Y, and choosing A will guarantee me at least 5 points regardless of Player 1's choice, I decide to choose A."""
-9,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. Comparing the possible outcomes, I can see that if Player 1 chooses X, I'll get a guaranteed 5 points with option B, whereas option A would give me only 10 points, assuming Player 1 makes that choice. Since I want to maximize my score, I chose option B (B)."""
-10,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""Since the highest reward for Player 2 is 10 points, I will choose action 'A' to maximize my payoff and ensure a potential gain of 10 points."""
-11,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""Since Player 1 can get either 15 points (by choosing X and I choosing B) or 5 points (by choosing Y and I also choosing B), maximizing my own payoff, I will choose B to guarantee 5 points for myself while giving Player 1 a choice of getting either 5 or 0 points."""
-12,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""I choose option A because it is a risk-free strategy that guarantees a non-negative payoff for me. If Player 1 chooses Y, I will get 5 points and if they choose X, I'll get 10 points. This choice allows me to maximize my expected payoff while minimizing potential losses."""
-13,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""I choose B because it guarantees a minimum profit of 5 points for me, regardless of Player 1's choice. This is the safest option to maximize my payoff."""
-14,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. Since choosing A can result in a draw (5 points for both players) and avoiding the loss scenario where Player 1 gets 15 points, I choose action A to minimize the risk."""
-15,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. When Player 1 chooses Y, I can get 5 points by choosing B, which is better than the 0 points I would get for choosing A. When Player 1 chooses X, it's a mixed strategy between getting 10 and 5 points. Since there's no clear dominant strategy, I choose B to diversify my possible outcomes and ensure a minimum of 5 points."""
-16,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""I'm choosing 'A' because it maximizes my payoff in every scenario. If Player 1 chooses Y, I'll receive either 5 points or 10 points, both of which are better than the 0 points I would get if they choose X and I choose B. Additionally, if Player 1 chooses X, I can ensure a positive score by choosing 'A' and receiving 10 points."""
-17,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""Considering the game rules, choosing B gives me a payoff of 5 points if Player 1 chooses X and 0 points if they choose Y. This is a safer option as it limits my potential loss to 5 points. I prioritize minimizing my potential losses over maximizing gains."""
-18,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. The optimal strategy for me would be to choose 'A' when Player 1 chooses 'X', and get a higher payoff of 10 points compared to the 5 points if I chose 'B'. Since there's no information about what Player 1 will do, I'll opt for the safer choice which gives me the highest possible reward in case they choose 'X'"""
-19,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""I choose B because it is a dominant strategy. Regardless of what Player 1 chooses, choosing B gives me the highest expected payoff. If Player 1 chooses X, I will get at least 5 points. If Player 1 chooses Y, I will also get at least 0 points. In contrast, if I choose A, my worst-case scenario is getting only 10 points if Player 1 chooses X."""
-20,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my payoff. Since the outcome (Player 1 choosing Y and I choosing B) gives me 10 points, it's a better option than choosing A or B with other combinations of moves. Therefore, my rational choice is to choose B."""
-21,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, my primary goal is to maximize my own payoff. Among the given options, choosing A would lead to a higher payoff (10 points) as compared to choosing B (5 points). Additionally, it's important to note that choosing A also leads to a lower payoff for Player 1 (10 points) as opposed to the possibility of them receiving 15 points if I chose B. Considering these factors, I decide to choose A to maximize my own gain."""
-22,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""I have analyzed the game rules and decided to choose 'A' as my action. This is because choosing 'A' results in a draw with 5 points for both myself and Player 1 (since neither of us wants Player 1 to get more than they're eligible to), while 'B' would only give Player 1 15 points, which I don't believe maximizes my payoff."""
-23,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, my goal is to maximize my own payoff. I can see that if Player 1 chooses X, I would receive 10 points by choosing A, but only 5 points by choosing B. Since 10 > 5, it's better for me to choose A in this scenario. However, if Player 1 chooses Y, I would receive 0 points by choosing A and lose to them immediately. By choosing B instead, I have a chance to earn 5 points which is still my maximum possible payoff. Therefore, the rational choice for me as Player 2 is to choose B."""
-24,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""I choose 'A' because it is a dominant strategy for Player 2. If Player 1 chooses X, I will get 10 points by choosing 'A'. If Player 1 chooses Y, I will also get 5 points by choosing 'A', which is better than getting only 10 points if Player 1 chooses B."""
-25,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""Since the main goal is to maximize my own payoff, I will choose 'B'. This is because if Player 1 chooses X and I choose B, we both receive 5 points, which is a more favorable outcome for me compared to choosing A and risking a lower payoff. Additionally, if Player 1 chooses Y and I choose B, I guarantee a 10-point reward, whereas choosing A only yields 0 points in that scenario. Thus, the highest expected value comes from choosing 'B'."""
-26,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""I'll choose 'A' because it's the only option that can guarantee me a higher payoff. If I choose 'B', Player 1 will get 15 points and I'll get 10, which is not the optimal strategy for Player 2. On the other hand, choosing 'A' ensures that either I'll get 5 points or Player 1 will get 0 points, while I won't get stuck with a low payoff if they choose differently."""
-27,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""I want to minimize the payoff to Player 1 by choosing B, as it gives them only 5 points regardless of their move. This strategy ensures I get at least 5 points, either by getting 5 points myself (if they choose X) or by preventing them from getting more than 15 points."""
-28,llama3,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""Since I'm Player 2, my goal is to maximize my payoff. Comparing the different payoffs, if Player 1 chooses Y, giving them 15 points would be unprofitable for me. If they choose X, I can guarantee at least 5 points by choosing A. Therefore, my rational choice is to choose A."""
-29,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""As Player 2, I aim to maximize my own payoff. Choosing B gives me the highest potential reward in all four possible scenarios. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with B and 10 points if they choose Y. This maximization strategy appears to be the most rational decision given the game rules."""
-30,llama3,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Since Player 1 can choose to select Y and receive 15 points if I choose B, it is my best option to minimize their payoff. By choosing B, I ensure that they will only get 10 points and I receive the same."""
-1,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A compared to 5 with B. If Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points by picking A whereas if i choose B, I will get zero."""
-2,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' is the rational decision because it maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points. Choosing 'A' would result in lower or equal rewards (5 points and 0 points respectively), hence choosing 'B' is the optimal strategy."""
-3,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff irrespective of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I get 5 points. Choosing 'B' would result in only 5 points or 0 points depending on Player 1’s choice. Therefore, choosing A is the rational strategy."""
-4,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points. Choosing A would mean I do better in certain scenarios but do worse than selecting B in others."""
-5,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A ensures a better outcome."""
-6,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff in all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses 'Y,' I get 10 points by choosing 'B'; if Player 1 chooses 'X,' I still get 5 points, which is better than the 0 points I would receive by choosing 'A'. Since A is strictly dominated B seems the best approach."""
-7,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Given that choosing B is strictly dominated by choosing A, meaning A always provides a better payoff regardless of Player 1's move, the rational choice for Player 2 is to choose A to maximize their own points."""
-8,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff in all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points compared to 5 if I choose A. If Player 1 chooses X, I still get better outcomes by choosing B rather than being zeroed out from the dominated move of player 1."""
-9,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""As Player 2, I need to maximize my own payoff. By choosing 'A', I can ensure that I get the highest possible points in any scenario."""
-10,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' is the rational move because it guarantees a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points instead of 5 (both when choosing A). If Player 1 chooses X, then if I choose B I end up with 5 points."""
-11,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff in both scenarios where Player 1 chooses either X (I get 10 points) or Y (I get 5 points). Choosing B would result in lower or equal payoffs depending on Player 1's choice, making A the strictly dominant strategy."""
-12,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points. Choosing A would result in lower or equal points compared to B."""
-13,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff in both scenarios. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses 'Y', I still get 5 points."""
-14,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points. Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B is the rational decision."""
-15,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses 'Y', I still get 5 points. In contrast, choosing 'B' would result in either 5 or 0 points, which is less optimal."""
-16,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's decision since A is strictly dominated by B."""
-17,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff in both scenarios where Player 1 chooses X and Y. It also avoids a situation with the minimum points which is 0."""
-18,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's move. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points. Choosing A would result in a lower payoff (either 0 or 5 points)."""
-19,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' is the rational decision because it maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses 'Y', I still get 5 points, but these are not less than what you would give in such cases when choosing B (which leads to only zero in case Y is chosen)."""
-20,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff in all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points with 'B', and if Player 1 chooses 'X', I still get a positive payoff of 5 points."""
-21,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff in all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A versus 5 points with B. If Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points with A, whereas with B I get nothing."""
-22,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff in all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B compared to only 5 points with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I still get a better outcome with (0 points for P2 using A) or at least the same as when choosing B (5 points but better by P2). Therefore, rational choice is always opting for B."""
-23,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' is the rational decision because it maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A but only 5 points with B. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 5 points with A and nothing (0 points) with B. Additionally, choosing 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', which confirms that picking A leads to better outcomes in all scenarios."""
-24,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points."""
-25,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A and only 5 points with B. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 5 points with A and 0 points with B. Since 'B' is strictly dominated by 'A', the rational choice is to select 'A'."""
-26,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' is the rational decision because it strictly dominates choosing 'A'. This means that regardless of Player 1's choice, selecting 'B' will always result in a higher or equal payoff for me compared to choosing 'A'. Specifically, if Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points by choosing B as opposed to 5 with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points by choosing B versus 0 with A."""
-27,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""I chose 'A' because it is a rational decision based on the rules provided. Choosing 'A' ensures that regardless of Player 1's move (X or Y), my payoff will be better than if I had chosen 'B'. Specifically, choosing 'A' guarantees me 5 points in case player one choses Y and 10 with X which is more compared to B."""
-28,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff in all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B compared to 5 points with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with B while getting 0 points choosing A."""
-29,mistral-small,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my own payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A and only 5 points if they choose B."""
-30,mistral-small,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes Player 2's payoff in all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses 'X', I still get the highest payoff."""
-1,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff in both scenarios. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get a decent score of 5 points"""
-2,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Player 2 has strictly higher payoffs when choosing B over A. Since A is strictly dominated by B, and I don't know the opponent's decision yet."""
-3,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would never be better."""
-4,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since B strictly dominates A, choosing B guarantees a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I will get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses X, I will still get 5 points."""
-5,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I chose 'A' because it provides a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points with A instead of 5 points with B. If Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points with A, the same as B but with an advantage in most scenarios"""
-6,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B is the rational decision because it maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B compared to 5 points with A. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points with B instead of 0 points with A."""
-7,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Choosing 'B' would only give me 5 points if Player 1 chooses X and 0 points if Player 1 chooses Y."""
-8,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff in all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points compared to 5 points if I choose 'A'. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I still get 5 points with either choice but choosing B does not reduce my earning potential."""
-9,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses 'Y', I still get 5 points. Choosing 'B' would result in 5 points at best which is strictly dominated by the 10 or 5 with A."""
-10,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my own payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points. If Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points. Choosing A would give me either 5 or 0 points depending on Player 1’s move—so it is less advantageous."""
-11,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' is the optimal strategy because it guarantees a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A maximizes my potential payoff."""
-12,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""I chose B because it is a strictly dominant strategy. Regardless of Player 1's choice, choosing B either matches the point they get when I choose 'A' or gives me more points. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points for choosing B while if they choose X, I receive 5 points which is better than getting nothing."""
-13,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes the minimum payoff. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Choosing B leads to either a lower guaranteed payoff of 5 or 0 points."""
-14,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""I chose 'B' because it is the dominant strategy. It yields a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points with B compared to only 5 with A. If Player 1 chooses X, then choosing B will give me still some profit (I get 5 points) rather than getting nothing when picking A."""
-15,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I chose 'A' because it is strictly dominant over 'B'. By choosing 'A', I ensure that regardless of Player 1's move, I get the highest payoff possible (10 points if Player 1 chooses X and 5 points if Player 1 chooses Y). Therefore choosing A maximizes my own payoff."""
-16,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points. Choosing A would result in only 5 points if Player 1 chooses Y and no points if Player 1 chooses X."""
-17,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Choosing 'B' would result in only 5 points if Player 1 chooses X and 0 points if Player 1 chooses Y. Therefore, 'A' is the optimal choice."""
-18,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""I chose B because it is the strictly dominant strategy. Regardless of Player 1's choice, selecting B will either match or maximize my payoff, ensuring I always get a higher return based on these rules."""
-19,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Choosing 'B' would result in lower or equal points depending on Player 1's choice and this strategy is strictly dominated by 'A'."""
-20,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Player B is maximized by choosing B, because A is strictly dominated strategy for player 2. In all situations with B as a move there isn't a situation where Player 1 and 2 can receive more than 5 points."""
-21,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses 'Y,' I get 5 points."""
-22,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""I chose B because it is the dominant strategy for Player 2. Regardless of Player 1's choice, choosing B yields a higher payoff (10 points if Player 1 chooses Y and 5 points if Player 1 chooses X). A is strictly dominated by B."""
-23,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Choosing 'B' would result in either 5 points or 0 points depending on Player 1's move, which is less optimal."""
-24,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff in all scenarios. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 5 points. Since 'A' is strictly dominated by 'B', choosing 'B' ensures a higher or equal payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
-25,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Choosing 'B' only gives me 5 or 0 points, which is less optimal."""
-26,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 5 points. Since 'A' is strictly dominated by 'B', choosing 'B' ensures a better outcome for me in all scenarios."""
-27,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I chose 'A' because it is strictly dominant over 'B'. Regardless of Player 1's choice, selecting 'A' will either give me more points (when Player 1 chooses X) or the same points with an additional outcome. It ensures a higher payoff."""
-28,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff because it either gets me 10 points (if Player 1 chooses Y) or at least 5 points (if Player 1 chooses X). Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing A would never be optimal."""
-29,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing B would never give me a higher payoff than choosing A."""
-30,mistral-small,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses 'X', I still get 5 points."""
-1,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points. If Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points. This strategy ensures I always get a positive payoff."""
-2,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my own payoff since if Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points instead of 5. If Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points which means that I have nothing to lose by choosing B over A."""
-3,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my potential payoff. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points. However, If Player 1 chooses Y, I still have a chance for getting 0 points but avoiding the high loss that Player 2 has."""
-4,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I chose B because it maximizes my potential payoff. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points. Choosing A only guarantees me a maximum of 5 points and could result in 0 points."""
-5,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' ensures that I get at least 10 points if Player 1 chooses 'X'. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I still get 5 points. This strategy maximizes my minimum payoff."""
-6,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I chose B because it gives me the highest possible payoff (10 points) if Player 1 chooses Y, and in the worst case I only get 5 points which is not worse than getting 0 points in case i choose A. It minimizes my chance to receive no reward."""
-7,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff in one scenario and provides a decent payoff in the other. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points. If Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 5 points, which is better than getting 0 points by choosing B."""
-8,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 5 points. In both scenarios in X or Y choosing will maximize the value for me"""
-9,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""By choosing 'A', I maximize my potential payoff. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 10 points, which is the highest possible payoff for me. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I still get 5 points, which is better than getting 0 points if I choose 'B' and Player 1 chooses 'Y'."""
-10,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff in both scenarios. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points."""
-11,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get a significant boost."""
-12,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of what Player 1 chooses. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points. Choosing A would give me only 5 points if Player 1 chooses Y and 0 points if Player 1 chooses X."""
-13,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points, and if Player 1 chooses Y, I still get 0 points but prevent Player 2 from scoring high if they choose A."""
-14,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""By choosing B, I maximize my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points."""
-15,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff in the case where Player 1 chooses 'X', giving me 10 points. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I will still get 5 points, which is better than choosing 'B' when Player 1 picks X."""
-16,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff in both scenarios where Player 1 chooses X (I get 0 points) or Y (I get 5 points). By choosing A, I will have to deal with the uncertainty of whether Player 2 will do worse than expected."""
-17,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my payoff in one scenario (10 points if Player 1 chooses X) and minimizes the maximum possible loss from a potential suboptimal strategy by player one. Choosing B has no advantage over A"""
-18,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff in both scenarios where Player 1 chooses 'Y' or 'X'. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses 'X', I still get 5 points. Choosing 'A' would result in either a tie with player one (at five pips) or no score."""
-19,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""I chose option 'A' because it guarantees me at least 5 points, it maximizes my payoff to 10 by cooperating with player one."""
-20,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my payoff in both scenarios. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points (which is more than the 5 points from choosing 'A'). If Player 1 chooses 'X', I still get 5 points (compared to 0 points from choosing 'A')."""
-21,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""By choosing 'A', I ensure that Player 1 will receive the most points (15) and I receive a decent amount (10 points). This maximizes stability and is beneficial if both players attempt at maximixing the highest total combined score"""
-22,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes Player 2's payoff in most cases. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses 'X', I still get 5 points."""
-23,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff. If Player 1 chooses X, I get 5 points, and if Player 1 chooses Y, I get 0 points. Since choosing B ensures at least 5 points against X, it is rational when aiming to maximize the outcome for myself."""
-24,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff if Player 1 chooses Y since I get higher points. Even if Player 1 chooses X, I still receive some points but I avoid receiving 0 if Player 1 decides on that move."""
-25,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""Player 2 should choose 'B' because it minimizes the chance of receiving 0 points, and the worst-case scenario (when Player 1 chooses X) is still getting 5 points compared to 10 when choosing A which depends on player one's decision. Therefore, strategically Player 2 will go for point B."""
-26,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my potential payoff. If Player 1 chooses 'Y', I get 10 points, which is higher than the 5 points I would get if Player 1 chooses either option when I choose 'A'."""
-27,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""By choosing 'A', I maximize my payoff in the worst-case scenario. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 10 points, and if Player 1 chooses 'Y', I still get 5 points. This strategy ensures that regardless of Player 1's choice, I have a guaranteed positive payoff."""
-28,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing 'B' maximizes my potential payoff. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points, which is higher than the 5 points I would get if Player 1 chooses X. If Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points."""
-29,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Choosing 'A' maximizes my minimum payoff. If Player 1 chooses 'X', I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses 'Y', I still get 5 points. This strategy ensures I never end up with 0 points."""
-30,mistral-small,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice. If Player 1 chooses Y, I get 10 points; if Player 1 chooses X, I still get 5 points."""
-1,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A maximizes my payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
-2,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,
-3,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,
-4,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,
-5,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since Player 2 prefers higher payoffs, choosing A yields more points for them."""
-6,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since option B strictly dominates option A, choosing B leads to better outcomes in all scenarios. As a rational player aiming to maximize my payoff, I will select B."""
-7,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Player 2 should choose A because it dominates B."""
-8,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,
-9,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,
-10,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Player 2 must choose B if she is rational."""
-11,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,0.0,
-12,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,
-13,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,
-14,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,
-15,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,0.0,
-16,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since Player 2 can maximize their own payoff by choosing B instead of A, as shown in the game rules, it is strictly dominant for them to select B."""
-17,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,
-18,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since player 2 wants to maximize her score, choosing B gives a higher payoff for all possible moves by Player 1."""
-19,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,
-20,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since Player 2's strategy to choose B dominates all other options, particularly because Y is strictly dominated by B for Player 1. Therefore, choosing B ensures higher payoff compared to A."""
-21,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Player 2 should choose 'A' because B is dominated by A."""
-22,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,0.0,
-23,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A maximizes my payoff in all scenarios."""
-24,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since Player 2 is rational, she should choose B because A is strictly dominated by B."""
-25,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,A,1.0,"""B is strictly dominated by A, so I should choose A to maximize my payoff."""
-26,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Player 2 should choose B because, given that Player 1's strategies for X and Y are countered by higher payoffs when Player 2 chooses B over A."""
-27,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,0.0,"""Because I will take the dominated strategy to maximize my points."""
-28,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,
-29,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,0.0,
-30,deepseek-r1,0.7,Given,B,1.0,"""Since option A is strictly dominated by B, choosing B ensures a better outcome for player 2 regardless of player 1's choice."""
-1,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,
-2,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, I choose B to maximize my minimum gain."""
-3,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Because option B is strictly worse for me, I will choose A instead."""
-4,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since A is strictly dominated by B, choosing option B will give me a higher payoff regardless of Player 1's choice."""
-5,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I choose A because it dominates B when Player 1 chooses Y, ensuring I get at least 5 points instead of possibly 0."""
-6,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""I choose B because..."""
-7,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,0.0,"""..."""
-8,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,0.0,
-9,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,0.0,"""I choose B because it leads to mutual cooperation and higher payoffs for both players."""
-10,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,0.0,
-11,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""I choose to play A because it dominates B in all scenarios where Player 1 chooses X or Y."""
-12,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""I choose B because it dominates all other options"""
-13,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,0.0,"""Because I choose according to my best strategy since B is dominated by A."""
-14,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,0.0,"""Player 1 may choose X over Y since Player 2 should maximize their own payoff."""
-15,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,0.0,"""Because I prefer getting 10 points over 5, even if it meant losing some other potential."""
-16,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Player 2 should choose B because it is strictly dominated by A and dominates the potential lower payoffs."""
-17,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""..."""
-18,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,0.0,"""..."""
-19,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,0.0,"""I choose B because it offers potential higher points compared to A."""
-20,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""I choose B because it dominates over both Y and X for Player 1."""
-21,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,
-22,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,0.0,"""Because selecting A gives me at least 0 points even if Player 1 chooses X, while B might give fewer."""
-23,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,0.0,"""I choose B because it gives a higher payoff when Player 1 chooses Y, which seems to be a better outcome for me."""
-24,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,0.0,
-25,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Player 2 has no incentive to choose B as it is strictly dominated by A."""
-26,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since option B is strictly dominated by A, I will choose B to maximize my own payoff."""
-27,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,A,1.0,"""Since B is strictly dominated by A, choosing A maximizes my payoff in all scenarios."""
-28,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since Player 1 is playing X, choosing B gives me a better payoff than A."""
-29,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,0.0,
-30,deepseek-r1,0.7,Explicit,B,1.0,"""Since Player 1 is choosing X and I, as a rational Player 2, I should stick with the optimal strategy to maximize my payoffs. Given that 'A' strictly dominates 'X', choosing B provides me higher points in all possible scenarios."""
-1,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,
-2,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B maximizes my points when Player 1 chooses Y."""
-3,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""..."""
-4,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,
-5,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""Choosing B gives me 5 points if Player 1 chose A, but I risk getting 0 by not choosing B when Player 1 chooses Y..."""
-6,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I choose B based on..."""
-7,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,
-8,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""..."""
-9,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,
-10,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""..."""
-11,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,"""I want to maximize my own payoff and also ensure Player 1 does not get too many points if they choose Y."""
-12,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Because option B gives a higher payoff when Player 1 chooses X. If I choose B, I can get up to 10 points if Player 2 also chooses B, which seems beneficial."""
-13,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,
-14,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I chose B because it's the most reliable option that ensures I at least get 5 points in two scenarios."""
-15,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,
-16,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I want to maximize my own payoff, so I will choose B."""
-17,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""..."""
-18,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Choosing B gives a better payoff for Player 2 regardless of Player 1's choice."""
-19,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""My goal is to maximize my own payoff, so choosing A gives me 10 points if Player 1 chooses B and only 5 if they choose A."""
-20,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,
-21,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,
-22,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""To maximize my payoffs, I should choose the option that gives me the highest points based on Player 1's possible choices."""
-23,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Player 1 might prioritize getting more points when they choose X, so I should aim for a scenario where if Player 1 selects Y in conjunction with my move B gives them some success while I avoid giving the opponent too many points"""
-24,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,"""I choose A because it results in 10 points for me if Player 1 plays X, which seems like the best option."""
-25,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,
-26,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""Optimizing for maximum points when Player 1 chooses Y is better as B gives higher points to Player 2."""
-27,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,1.0,"""Exploring the possibility of mutual cooperation to achieve higher collective payoff."""
-28,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,1.0,"""I need to maximize my own payoff while considering Player 1's possible moves."""
-29,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,B,0.0,
-30,deepseek-r1,0.7,Implicit,A,0.0,
diff --git a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.a.csv b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.a.csv
index b8d8da9c9ffd1d5ac9f3f08c3544037a24315f68..5fed74b5e026b3368ff85a6df012206b4c962d71 100644
--- a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.a.csv
+++ b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.a.csv
@@ -1,4 +1,5 @@
Model,Given,Explicit,Implicit
deepseek-r1,0.8,0.5333333333333333,0.5666666666666667
+gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,1.0,1.0,1.0
llama3,0.9666666666666667,1.0,1.0
mistral-small,0.9333333333333333,0.9666666666666667,1.0
diff --git a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.b.csv b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.b.csv
index c0fcd0d224f4525569e1fb90cf6d228665e87705..95a677ea025fd4fad115dfe966663ffcd853641f 100644
--- a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.b.csv
+++ b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.b.csv
@@ -1,4 +1,5 @@
Model,Given,Explicit,Implicit
deepseek-r1,0.6666666666666666,0.6,0.5333333333333333
+gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,1.0,0.7666666666666667,0.0
llama3,0.7666666666666667,0.8,0.6
mistral-small,0.8666666666666667,0.7666666666666667,0.6
diff --git a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.c.csv b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.c.csv
index be65193c571ccaf3b8567b31319f23d2209431d3..e9c00514b051cc89818994733b4760fd332a9c91 100644
--- a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.c.csv
+++ b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.c.csv
@@ -1,4 +1,5 @@
Model,Given,Explicit,Implicit
deepseek-r1,0.6666666666666666,0.6333333333333333,0.4666666666666667
+gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.8666666666666667,0.8333333333333334,0.0
llama3,0.9666666666666667,0.9,0.9333333333333333
mistral-small,0.7666666666666667,0.6,0.7
diff --git a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.d.csv b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.d.csv
index e02813edd27604601e7d3c076820fec8bdecc666..94d5bc5db25f2758956cbf80796b15c79d1c9ac9 100644
--- a/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.d.csv
+++ b/figures/ring/ring_accuracy.1.d.csv
@@ -1,4 +1,5 @@
Model,Given,Explicit,Implicit
deepseek-r1,0.7,0.5,0.5666666666666667
+gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27,0.5,0.9,0.0
llama3,0.8333333333333334,0.9,0.6
mistral-small,0.7333333333333333,0.5666666666666667,0.36666666666666664
diff --git a/src/ring/ring_experiments.py b/src/ring/ring_experiments.py
index 6a3149659f2e246e03831243a20d717c6399c297..7b984914c56c02194cdfcc163ce9f892a09706e7 100644
--- a/src/ring/ring_experiments.py
+++ b/src/ring/ring_experiments.py
@@ -77,11 +77,11 @@ class RingExperiment:
# Running the experiment
if __name__ == "__main__":
- models = ["llama3", "mistral-small", "deepseek-r1"] # or gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27
+ models = ["llama3", "mistral-small", "deepseek-r1"] # gpt-4.5-preview-2025-02-27 can be added to the list
temperature = 0.7
iterations = 30
player_id = 1
- version = "a"
+ version = "d"
output_file = f"../../data/ring/ring.{player_id}.{version}.csv"
experiment = RingExperiment(models=models, player_id = player_id, version = version, temperature = temperature, iterations=iterations, output_file = output_file)
asyncio.run(experiment.run_experiment())
diff --git a/src/ring/ring_player2_draw.py b/src/ring/ring_player2_draw.py
index 89071ccfe9591e46111616a145d5fb7674c3e20c..3a94e3bf3cdeea8d09a9b054a8159bf244feafe3 100644
--- a/src/ring/ring_player2_draw.py
+++ b/src/ring/ring_player2_draw.py
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
import pandas as pd
# Load the experiment results
-df = pd.read_csv("../../data/ring/ring.2.csv")
+df = pd.read_csv("../../data/ring/ring.2.a.csv")
# Calculate the accuracy by model and belief
accuracy_table = df.groupby(["Model", "Belief"])["rationality"].mean().unstack()
desired_order = ["Given", "Explicit", "Implicit"]
@@ -8,4 +8,4 @@ accuracy_table = accuracy_table.reindex(columns=desired_order)
# Display the table
print(accuracy_table)
# Save the table as a CSV file for future use
-accuracy_table.to_csv("../../figures/ring/ring_accuracy.2.csv")
\ No newline at end of file
+accuracy_table.to_csv("../../figures/ring/ring_accuracy.2.a.csv")
\ No newline at end of file