Article: remarks PN updated

Article/Expe_auto/perfTable.tex

@@ -12,7 +12,8 @@ $M_{new}/M_{old}$ (\%) & & & & \\
 \hspace{0.4cm} on image of \RefFig{fig:auto}
 & \multicolumn{1}{l|}{87.60} & \multicolumn{1}{l|}{115.03}
 & \multicolumn{1}{l|}{86.18} & \multicolumn{1}{l|}{87.85} \\
-\hspace{0.4cm} on the set of test images & & & & \\
+\hspace{0.4cm} on the set of test images
+& 85.88 $\pm$ 2.60 & 106.64 $\pm$ 5.63 & 92.63 $\pm$ 4.37 & 87.03 $\pm$ 4.27 \\
 \hspace{0.4cm} on CannyLines images
 & 86.02 $\pm$ 2.44 & 110.15 $\pm$ 6.51 & 89.23 $\pm$ 5.11 & 84.70 $\pm$ 2.98 \\
 \hline

Article/Expe_perf/PerfCompare.java

+import java.io.*;
+
+public class PerfCompare
+{
+  private static String[] names = {
+    "perf_iut_amphi1.txt",
+    "perf_iut_amphi2.txt",
+    "perf_iut_corridor1.txt",
+    "perf_iut_corridor2.txt",
+    "perf_iut_entrance.txt",
+    "perf_iut_labo1.txt",
+    "perf_iut_labo2.txt",
+    "perf_iut_library1.txt",
+    "perf_iut_mul1.txt",
+    "perf_iut_mul2.txt",
+    "perf_iut_office1.txt",
+    "perf_iut_office2.txt",
+    "perf_iut_office4.txt",
+    "perf_iut_outdoor1.txt",
+    "perf_iut_outdoor2.txt",
+    "perf_iut_outdoor3.txt",
+    "perf_iut_scc1.txt",
+    "perf_iut_scc2.txt",
+    "perf_iut_scc3.txt",
+    "perf_loria_indoor1.txt",
+    "perf_loria_indoor2.txt",
+    "perf_loria_indoor3.txt",
+    "perf_loria_office1.txt",
+    "perf_loria_outdoor1.txt",
+    "perf_vosges_castle1.txt",
+    "perf_vosges_castle2.txt",
+    "perf_vosges_corridor1.txt",
+    "perf_vosges_detail1.txt",
+    "perf_vosges_detail2.txt",
+    "perf_vosges_detail3.txt"};
+
+
+  private double timeRatio = 0.;
+  private double countRatio = 0.;
+  private double longRatio = 0.;
+  private double lengthRatio = 0.;
+  private double widthRatio = 0.;
+
+  public static void main (String[] args) throws IOException
+  {
+    PerfCompare[] perf = new PerfCompare[names.length];
+    double meanTime = 0.;
+    double meanCount = 0.;
+    double meanLong = 0.;
+    double meanLength = 0.;
+    double meanWidth = 0.;
+
+    for (int i = 0; i < names.length; i++)
+    {
+      perf[i] = new PerfCompare (names[i]);
+      meanTime += perf[i].timeRatio;
+      meanCount += perf[i].countRatio;
+      meanLong += perf[i].longRatio;
+      meanLength += perf[i].lengthRatio;
+      meanWidth += perf[i].widthRatio;
+    }
+    meanTime /= names.length;
+    meanCount /= names.length;
+    meanLong /= names.length;
+    meanLength /= names.length;
+    meanWidth /= names.length;
+
+    double sdTime = 0.;
+    double sdCount = 0.;
+    double sdLong = 0.;
+    double sdLength = 0.;
+    double sdWidth = 0.;
+    for (int i = 0; i < names.length; i++)
+    {
+      sdTime += (perf[i].timeRatio - meanTime)
+                * (perf[i].timeRatio - meanTime);
+      sdCount += (perf[i].countRatio - meanCount)
+                 * (perf[i].countRatio - meanCount);
+      sdLong += (perf[i].longRatio - meanLong)
+                * (perf[i].longRatio - meanLong);
+      sdLength += (perf[i].lengthRatio - meanLength)
+                  * (perf[i].lengthRatio - meanLength);
+      sdWidth += (perf[i].widthRatio - meanWidth)
+                 * (perf[i].widthRatio - meanWidth);
+    }
+    sdTime = Math.sqrt (sdTime / names.length);
+    sdCount = Math.sqrt (sdCount / names.length);
+    sdLong = Math.sqrt (sdLong / names.length);
+    sdLength = Math.sqrt (sdLength / names.length);
+    sdWidth = Math.sqrt (sdWidth / names.length);
+
+    System.out.println ("Time    : " + meanTime + " (" + sdTime + ")");
+    System.out.println ("Count   : " + meanCount + " (" + sdCount + ")");
+    System.out.println ("Long    : " + meanLong + " (" + sdLong + ")");
+    System.out.println ("Lendth  : " + meanLength + " (" + sdLength + ")");
+    System.out.println ("Width   : " + meanWidth + " (" + sdWidth + ")");
+  }
+
+  public PerfCompare (String name) throws IOException
+  {
+    BufferedReader flot = new BufferedReader (new FileReader (name));
+    String val = flot.readLine ();  // nb runs
+    val = flot.readLine ();  // width
+    val = flot.readLine ();  // height
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // time
+    double t1 = (new Double (val)).doubleValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // trials
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // count of segments
+    int ns1 = (new Integer (val)).intValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // count of long segments
+    int nl1 = (new Integer (val)).intValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // mean length
+    double l1 = (new Double (val)).doubleValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // mean width
+    double w1 = (new Double (val)).doubleValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // mean width of long segments
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // time
+    double t2 = (new Double (val)).doubleValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // trials
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // count of segments
+    int ns2 = (new Integer (val)).intValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // count of long segments
+    int nl2 = (new Integer (val)).intValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // mean length
+    double l2 = (new Double (val)).doubleValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // mean width
+    double w2 = (new Double (val)).doubleValue ();
+    val = flot.readLine ();   // mean width of long segments
+    flot.close ();
+
+    timeRatio = t1 / t2;
+    countRatio = ns1 / (double) ns2;
+    longRatio = nl1 / (double) nl2;
+    lengthRatio = l1 / l2;
+    widthRatio = w1 / w2;
+  }
+}

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_amphi1.txt

+100
+768
+512
+4.6903
+1806
+660
+150
+30.5512
+2.27963
+2.2943
+5.72459
+1814
+636
+150
+31.725
+2.57986
+2.65468

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_amphi2.txt

+100
+768
+512
+6.40191
+2748
+1047
+148
+23.4331
+2.29331
+2.60233
+7.43268
+2638
+942
+171
+26.4888
+2.63111
+2.94765

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_corridor1.txt

+100
+512
+768
+3.00952
+1219
+435
+113
+33.3889
+1.96156
+1.98553
+3.52095
+1191
+375
+101
+38.4183
+2.6502
+2.71477

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_corridor2.txt

+100
+768
+512
+2.76221
+1174
+408
+86
+32.2011
+1.72083
+1.61854
+3.10034
+1074
+354
+82
+37.2489
+2.15799
+2.11399

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_entrance.txt

+100
+604
+435
+5.89507
+2873
+875
+145
+26.5632
+2.17234
+2.29212
+6.96728
+2791
+796
+163
+29.9855
+2.60888
+2.67866

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_labo1.txt

+100
+768
+512
+3.47058
+1210
+523
+124
+28.5383
+2.11452
+2.0609
+4.10393
+1186
+469
+129
+32.2115
+2.43933
+2.40623

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_labo2.txt

+100
+768
+512
+3.08177
+1070
+458
+92
+29.9653
+2.21609
+2.27448
+3.71473
+1011
+437
+113
+32.5916
+2.57131
+2.64624

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_library1.txt

+100
+768
+512
+6.69281
+3042
+1012
+147
+22.7012
+2.40284
+2.60964
+7.74526
+2915
+962
+170
+24.584
+2.79463
+2.91575

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_mul1.txt

+100
+768
+512
+4.99343
+2016
+738
+148
+27.4874
+2.04314
+1.95366
+5.89653
+2058
+687
+144
+28.4664
+2.3839
+2.31797

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_mul2.txt

+100
+768
+512
+4.00064
+1700
+614
+95
+24.8282
+2.15711
+2.15276
+4.69204
+1648
+579
+101
+26.3164
+2.40674
+2.41017

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_office1.txt

+100
+512
+768
+4.05439
+1657
+576
+125
+29.6341
+2.11351
+2.13721
+4.80129
+1600
+525
+122
+33.409
+2.50289
+2.54529

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_office2.txt

+100
+512
+768
+2.39764
+872
+347
+66
+28.6302
+2.16436
+2.11984
+2.82771
+808
+327
+69
+31.397
+2.4599
+2.45493

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_office4.txt

+100
+800
+533
+2.59955
+914
+352
+94
+33.2509
+2.17087
+2.21914
+3.0047
+851
+306
+85
+38.5787
+2.47154
+2.46201

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_outdoor1.txt

+100
+768
+512
+5.89527
+2667
+927
+114
+22.1006
+2.49616
+2.64012
+6.95665
+2642
+853
+138
+24.2389
+2.76982
+2.85027

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_outdoor2.txt

+100
+768
+512
+8.02477
+4230
+1196
+71
+14.7278
+2.63801
+2.28099
+8.66283
+4093
+1164
+75
+15.6502
+2.90617
+2.80733

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_outdoor3.txt

+100
+768
+512
+6.04887
+2686
+801
+188
+31.9457
+2.14241
+2.11146
+7.28111
+2577
+748
+211
+35.3597
+2.69916
+2.71961

Article/Expe_perf/perf_iut_scc1.txt

+100
+768
+512
+5.17888
+1969
+791
+155
+25.8714
+2.25773
+2.29206
+6.04807
+1871
+705
+154
+29.3372
+2.55873
+2.60574